Favorite to Least Favorite
#1. VWL-we just knew it was home the minute we walked in. Location (MK area), part of a full-service resort, theming, pool, Roaring Forks, atmosphere, can't beat it for Christmas
#2. BCV-this is where I would add-on in a heartbeat. Location (walk to EPCOT), gelato!, SAB, part of a full-service resort, just has a great "summer" feel to it
#3 & #4 Tie between OKW and BVW. If they were the only resorts available, I'd probably choose BWV.
OKW-Pluses: quieter, larger accommodations. Minuses: not a full-service resort, the neighborhood feel doesn't jazz me, no elevators, location, don't care for the separate buildings, all bus service.
BWV-Pluses: location (walk to EPCOT), full-service resort. I really didn't care for the feel or atmosphere of BWV, access to the shops and restaurants is a pain, long hallways.
#5. AKLV-Pluses: great atmosphere/theming, savanna views rock, nice restaurants, full-service resort. Minuses: Service is AWFUL, from the front desk to the bell-hops. Restaurant service was okay. Too far removed from everything, all bus service. Because of the service, I would not stay here again, even though the rooms and resort are very nice.
I have not stayed at SSR, HH, or VB, so I can't really comment on those. I am aiming to try them all!