Favorite sandwich at Earl of Sandwich

[mickeymousefan]

I love the Caprese. It is delicious!!!

 

[kjm4]

The Original followed closely by the Beef and Bleu.

 

[liznboys]

MMMMM, Earl... The Club is my favorite, but we've tried several and enjoy them all. I want one for lunch now.

 

[GoodFairies]

Jerk chicken

 

[alwayspooh]

This is on my list of new places to try the next time we go.

 

[mommystieg]

We LOVE the Earl of Sandwich We have eaten there twice on our last two visits. My favorite is the Florentine, DD#1 likes the tuna salad, DD#2 likes the pizza sandwich and I think DH likes the Montagu....

 

[angel's momma]

Our family's favorites are the Florentine & Montagu. We enjoyed breakfast there also.

 

[Cruz Family]

The Orignial (this thread is really making me hungry!)

 

[freakylick]

Well I decided that I was going to try to eat my way through the menu (except for the Tuna Melt...I hate tuna.). So far, I have tried-
-Cannonballs (For those that are Earl-illiterate, those are meatballs.)
-The Original (roast beef, cheddar, horseradish)
-The Scudetto (salami, capacola, ham and mortadella with fresh sliced mozzarella, roma tomatoes and marinara)
-The Full Montagu (roast beef and turkey with cheddar and swiss cheese, romaine lettuce, tomato and mustard sauce)

Next up...The Florentine!

To answer the OP, they were all incredible and I don't know that I could pick just one. The only thing that I can say is that my least favorite was probably Cannonballs. Don't get me wrong, it was very good too...but I am a little picky when it comes to meatballs. Since it seems that you have already picked the Scudetto as one sandwich, maybe make the Original the other...after all, it is the original Earl sandwich.

We love Earl so much that now we plan stops at Earl even when we are just driving through Orlando on the way to visit family.

 

[gharrer]

Stopped there this weekend on the way to Sebring and has the original. Very tasty.

 

[wvjovifan]

The Tuna Melt is to die for!!!!!!!!! YUMMMMM!!!!!!!

 

[durango kid]

The American is the Best turkey sandwich anywhere! he is a pic of it and the tuna salad, which is pretty awesome too!

 

[Cookie Princess]

I LOVE the original...bring on the horseradish!!!

 

[crazy4dizney]

carribean jerk chicken

 

[jwfla422]

Another vote for the Caprese. I don't think I can go there and not get it, it's just so darn good. I even try making a similar sandwich at home (of course it's just not the same LOL!!)

 

[frndofpooh]

Another vote for the Scudetto. Our tradition is to get two Scudettos to go as we are leaving WDW and then eat them later in the car as we are driving home.

 

[Lan]

TUNA MELT!!!!

 

[TDC Nala]

I have only had the Caprese but I think I would like it better if it wasn't heated. To me there is just something wrong about a mushy mozzarella and tomato sandwich. If I wanted a pizza I would buy one.