My favorite concierge experience is the Wilderness Lodge. We did a concierge stay at WL at Christmas one year and it was perfect. The high lobby and supertall, decorated tree w/ the fireplace and roaring waterfalls was perfect with the Christmas theme. I found the nicest CMs to be at WL cl...and the offerings were plentiful and delicious! I remember having a portuguese bean soup one night that was wonderful. We had a view of the castle from our seventh floor room and I loved eating breakfast while overlooking the festively decorated lobby in the mornings. We got all the little towel shapes, some like angels which were especially cool. It was great.
The concierge at the Beach club was lovely but the concierge room is really small and doesn't have any particular view except of the front/side of the resort. The food offerings were good but not as delicious as WL (could have just been what happened to be offering during our respective stays as both offered quite a bit of food). I loved the espresso/ cappucino/ latte machine at BC which I didn't notice at WL, but overall, at BC I'd probably spend the extra money for a water view (the Boardwalk lit up at night is great) and eat next door at all the wonderful epcot eateries (we LOVE Canada and France and even those Fish and chips).
I was disappointed with AKL's concierge service, probably mainly because it was really hyped up to me (I read so many glowing reports of it) and didn't understand the hype. It overlooks the lobby the same was WL does, so that is neat, but I thought the food offerings were better at WL. I guess I just wasn't as into the stuff like dunbar chicken and hummus and the like as I was into the WLs artiste pointe fare. Also, while our room was much larger and we had a gorgeous savannah view, there were chronic technical problems during our stay...our original ressie was lost, our sunrise safari reservation lost, we were checked our early and checked off housekeeping and turndown service lists, we were overcharged for the sunrise safari, etc. It was crazy! We've paid much, much less for stays at moderates and/ or the Swan/ Dolphin w/o any glitches whatsoever. A CM on DIS explained that it sounded like our ressie file was corrupted which caused the ongoing issues, so I bet if we stayed again I might have another opinion. But as it stands, it wasn't the smoothest experience and definitely not worth the extra cost. We also didn't get any towel animals or any extra special hospitality (at Beach club and WL the CMs were exceptionally nice)--nothing to make the experience stand out in any way from getting a regular room. I did really like the cappucino machine and the yogurt smoothies, yum. Again, I'd save the extra money for CL and go for a savannah view and go to BOMA or Jiko for the food, and still come out ahead

.
I'd love to try BWI's concierge and GFs concierge, and even the Contemporary's 14th floor CL with that great MK view. Lots to look forward to

.
