I had the New York Strip and it was cooked with really good flavor. I am a tenderloin kind of girl though, so it was a little fatty for me, but very tasty.
My husband had the Fettucini Alfredo and it was probably the best alfredo I have ever tasted. They use really good spices in their dishes.
Just an fyi if you have the dining plan - they try to get you to add on whatever you want. Our servers goal was to get our bill as high as he could (bigger tip for him). He ended up letting us add-on 2 and 3 things to our meal - chicken, shrimp, scallops.
Spoodles ended up being our most expensive meal - $240 for 3 adults and 2 children. We will definately go back if we do the dining plan. The atmosphere is really nice and the service was great.