we always stay onsite (POP = best value for us), there is no way we would get offsite. Getting a clean pool with lifeguards on duty, and Disney customer service, and free parking at parks + the convinience of the KTTW is something we would not want to miss.
We can't really afford moderates even with discounts.
Doing table service (Disney or off property) is not an option, since our budget is tight.
Eating out of property for lunch is fine, because with a young kid we do parks in the morning, go out for lunch, go back to hotel, nap, pool, and parks in the evening. So for us DDP almost means "ball and chain"
We are more than happy doing CiCis for example. Actually I've had better times at Cici's than I had at some Disney restaurants.
We make some table service, especially character meals for DS.
We made 6 TS during our stay, no actually we made 5, I was supposed to have character breakfast at Hollywood and vine, but the day before at Tusker House I got sick and spent all night in the bathroom and was unable to get up in the morning for our ADR (no show fee was waived)
I don't drink, none of us do, we get basically free beverages from the refillable mug, and we often eat in the room, either sandwiches or take out.
So yes, it's complex, and it depends on the guest. Still for our kind of needs, I still wonder if free DDP is really a good deal.
As I mentionned, for our style of vacation, we would have ended paying as much money if we had been on the free DDP.
And as far as the food is concerned, I was not very impressed by the food we got in WDW.
- Ohana's was great for the characters, but the food was no different and not better than what we had at Ihop, or at regular $6 buffets you can find all over the area.
- Boma's was fine but I get the same kind of food back home for half the price.
- Tomorrowland Terrace fireworks party was great, but only for the quiet, crowd free viewing. The dessert were the standard dessert you find in every restaurant in WDW
- Tusker House was fine, even if I got sick, but the food was far from being exceptional.
- Mama Melrose was good, but I could have made the same dish myself at home with the same taste (honest)
You may understand why I question the value of a free DDP. Of course there are many restaurants I have yet to experience, and they added new restaurants to the DDP, so that's even more to choose from. But I'm really not impressed so far, and the reviews I get from the hyped restaurants (eg Le Cellier) are not compelling either.
If it comes down to having bland tasting food, or something I could have cooked myself, then a hamburger or a pizza will do.
But once again I guess it's all a matter of taste.
I've done DDP before, and it was more a burden than anything else. This year I've done pizzas, burgers and sandwiches, I didn't spend as much as I would have on DDP (even free), and actually I think we all liked it better like that than being of the DDP
a matter of taste I guess
