I don't know if this helps, but I did a quick search on the American Airlines site, specifying NON-STOP leaving the NYC area on April 1 and returning on April 8.
I got two options going out, non-stop, at $184 and $282.
Returning from MCO on 4/8, I had multiple flights, all non-stop, from $154 to $262.
So that's $338-$544 with non-stop (3 hour) flights each way.
[ETA -- those prices were from and to JFK]
If you go to one of the travel sites and look for the cheapest flights, they will often give you some really UGLY connections. But if you go to the airline site, you'll usually get MUCH better flights at the same price.