Hi
We have rented 2 times already.... 1 bedroom @ BWV for 2 nights in May 2004, a studio @ BCV for 4 nights in Sept 2004, and our next trip is a 2 bedroom @ OKW in early Oct. 2005.
Different experiences at both so far. Overall like BWV better than BCV though the pool is an bonus @ BCV, but very happy with pool @ BWV... better kiddie pool than regular WDW resorts.
We rent because of the number of people we travel with.. cheaper than renting 2 hotel rooms and kitchen saves money on food. Plus we don't do parks more than 2 or 3 days tops.
Eventually, we'll get our own points, probably after this next trip to WDW... either a resale or at Saratoga Springs.
WE paid via money order for the rentals of BWV and BCv but I am paying through paypal for the OKW rental. $10/pt for all of them.
Feel free to ask any questions you have.
Suzanne
PS
If you are sure of resort you want and want to make sure you get it, find a renter who has an 11-month window or has points at that specific resort!