We am in the process of purchasing in SSR for first time, resale. Would TIW be a better deal than DDP. We are going in May with just our DS 15 and DD 19 but planning to take 7 more family members (3 teenagers, 1 child and 4 adults) on a trip in December 2012. Which would you recommend? How does TIW work?
It REALLY depends on your eating style. We have done both.
DDP is a lot of food. you get the best value if you eat TS for dinner and order expensive things. You can also save desserts (dessert either every meal..ahh) in the fridge for breakfast the next morning.
I think with a group as large as yours, depending on eating habits, esp if you're going to eat together most of the time, then TiW is a good choice. The discount extends to up to 10 people at your table. With that many people, you could easily make the money back from the card in 2-3 meals. Another option, if you feel your meals can fit into DDP would be to split the cost of TiW on top of that so you can get a discount on any extra TS meals or any adult beverages or appetizers you decide to add on.
Before the DDP we didn't eat many TS per trip. We were younger and poorer. On our last trip before the most recent one, we tried the DDP. It was a LOT of food. I had no fridge so 'd save desserts on ice to eat as breakfast or a snack the next day. We used our snack credits at the food and wine festival so it worked out. For us, it forced us to eat TS, and so we learned about new places and e really got into dining at Disney on that trip heras before, food was a way to keep us going touring, or a TS was for a sepcial treat.
This past trip we decided to do TiW. in 7 nights we had 7 TS meals, 2 of which would have cost 2 credits. We had probably about the same number of QS meals and virtually no snacks. The snacks however can be used to candy and other items that can be taken home.
We decided to do TiW since I felt the up front cost of DDP was scary. Really, it would have amounted to the same. Also, since we're taking at least 2 trips this year, I thought it would work out. I haven't looked at all of our receipts yet, but we actually almost made our money back on this one trip. I made DH save the receipts because I want to compare the savings on DDP vs. TiW for future reference.
I think for our October F&W trip, we might do DDP even though we already have TiW. TiW will save us money on our alcoholic beverages and any extra meals and we can get the benefit of using snacks for F&W portions. I think DH preferred doing DDP (he's the one who handles the bills) because it was all a pre-set amount. Even though DDP doesn't save you a lot of money, it's better to kno what you're spending in advance so you're not shocked by each $27 QS and $80 TS meal tab.
Sorry for that non-answer