We paid cash for the 4 of us for the Member Cruise. I didnt want to use points, in case we had to cancel. Cash was fully refundable up to the penalty period.
Also, there was a alot of disappointment when the points and cash costs of the
DVC member cruise were announced, many thought it was gouging and DVC taking advantage of the members. Many of us, who booked anyway, were happily surprised to find that the cost included all gratuities when we called to book that day.
We booked a Cat 9 for 2 adults and 2C under 10 and our 4 day was very comparable (DVC $120-$150 more) to
travel agent pricing (allseastravel.com) so thats where the extra points/cash came in. More than worth it, because DVC always puts so much into these events to make them extra special.
Hopefully DVC will offer the cruise again next year, but you can make an informed decision on the cost, because Im sure there will be plenty of griping again, about the cost.