Hey there, although this is our first time to Disney, we have decided to go with DxDP. For our family I can't imagine another alterative as good, although who knows what our reality will be.
Part of a fantastic trip for us is the dining experience - even our five-year-old LOVES to eat out. We don't eat outside the home as much as the average family as I find we can eat healthier at home. So when we do eat out, it is a super-fun experience for us.
We are touring for 10 days, and wanted the blessing of forced downtime in our trip. No rest breaks and food off our usual schedule 'causes a cranky family in our house. No point in touring if we are all shouting at one another because we are tired or hungry.
We are planning rope drop most days and really early breakfasts the few we do... (early rise, early to bed family)... lunch daily will be around 11/11:30 Dinner usually as soon as it opens for the particular restaurant... except for a couple.
We are also doing a bunch of Signature meals and Dinner Shows.
Including Hoop De Doo, Backyard BBQ, Spirit of Aloha, California Grill, CRT.
We also used our credits for Fantasmic preferred seating, and many, many character meals. To us the character meals are a must with our still imaginative DD. We are also dining at the Sci Fi, Coral Reef,and 50's PT... because although I've heard so-so remarks on the food - the dining experience sounds unique and fun.
Even with all these, we STILL have enough credits for Le Cellier, Teppan Edo, Boma, and have made reservations around parade time at Liberty Tree and for Illuminations at Rose and Crown hoping to get a good seat.
Except for character breakfasts - we will still need to have breakie in our room for several days because of all our two-credit meals. We should have lots of snack credits due to the amount of food to cover this... although DD and I are oatmeal in the morning kind of girls and after just finishing two weeks away - I've learned not to give up that fibre in the morning!!!
so it still completely works for us. (I plan on packing some bowls and a small kettle.)
Personally we only plan (at this point) to do CS a couple of times. I tend to find CS meals start to taste the same after a day or two regardless of where you stay or how good the food is. I know ten days of so much CS will make me super-cranky. But that's me, and I've heard over and over the CS is really good, so maybe this would be an exception... I'll probably find out for sure on another trip!
To figure out our ADRs, we decided on which park, which day and ate at the TS in that park we were interested in.... or if we wanted to do CRT on a certain day, that meant MK is our park that day. Booked Cali Grill on the night of my birthday (and the Neverland Club for DD) so MK is our park that night. All in all I booked at 180+10 and was able to secure all my requests within 10 mins.