well, I guess you can only go "downhill" if you are slipping. semantics here.
hubby and I LOVE disney. just returned from a July trip. going again in dec.
just becasue we keep returning doesn't mean we like "everything" going on. and no, you can't say, "well you keep coming back... so.... they are doing things right..."
last year, hubby Nebo started a thread much like this. listed a number of things we were disapointed with. (no more frozen coke at POP, we made a point to visit CSR hotel for their FF, which were repalced with crappy thin fries, much fewer dancers, etc. between the floats in Spectro, many more, too many to mention.)
little things, that only seasoned disney veterans would notice.
I can't beleive they keep raising the prices in this economy. I don't CARE if it's a business... DO NOT quote me and quote stock prices....I
know the whole "what the market will bear" theory. please, I do NOT want a lesson in economics 101!!!!!!
whew! that "disclaimer"..

out of the way...
It is MY OPINION (the OP asked for Opinions, I think it is still "her" thread")...
many people keep going because they "just, gol'darn it" love it. but we still see the "slipping" in many things.
that is what this thread is about. these various "slippings"
like how long is that
wonders of life pavilliongoing to sit empty. and what a great topic! don't even get me started on the "lack of Imagination" Pavillion.
I see it the most in the little things. the lack of cleanliness. I used to BRAG about how clean disney was compared to six flags, cedar point, Indiana beach, etc etc.
the ashtrays are over flowing (of course, it doesn't help that they eliminated half of the DSAs), there is garbage, wrappers, on the street (disney did a study on how far someone will walk with a scrap of paper before throwing on the ground, and situated the trash cans accordingly) but now, they are overflowing.
water fountains not working.(sorry, hubby has to take a blood pressure pill and shouldn't have to wait inline for free water at a CS)
cursory cleaning of the rooms (still good, MUCH better than the Knight's Inn on the way down

) but lots of dust under the beds, yucky whatever in the drawers, rings in the tub,toilet etc.) nothing I would call and complain about, but many do. just not"up to Disney par" which was "ALWAYS above and beyond" in the past. Disney spoiled me .. in the past... it was EXCELLENT!!! now it's acceptable.
one of the biggest disappointments is the CMS. I bragged to all my friends.. "at disney, you could stay at a value resort and still be treated like royalty!!!"
" in the parks, you look all ragged from a hot day, sweaty, etc. and any CM will treat you like you are the queen of england!"
now, I am NOT a high maintainence person. that is why it surprised me so much!
as a server, I never give a customer an "eye roll" no matter how busy I am. if a customer asks me for something, I never say "Yeah, I'll get to it in a minute!!! I'm busy right now!"
but the CMS, used to always be there (I don't mean in the restaurants, the servers there have been great) to answer your questions, or else find you the answer. numerous times in the past 2 years, WE ask a CM a question, and they act like "how should I know? not my job"
there was a Cm standing at the dock at BW for the whole purpose of telling you where the boat will go next. the CM replied "It goes to the Swan, and I think , maybe the Dolphin, too"

(for those who don't know, it's the same stop) another CM (at the store)told hubby the store opened at 9 AM. we like a newspaper. so he went down at 9 am and all the papers were gone becasue it o[pened at 8am.
the fountains at epcot was shut down for refurbishment. we asked a Cm at the gate "any idea when the fountain will be reopening?" answer.. "what fountain?"
I know, I know, you will tell me they were new, didn't know, etc etc.
my point being, it USED to be that CMS were always there to help you, and if not, lead you to the correct answer.
at a Counter service that served coffee "where can I get TEa?" " gee, I don't know." me, "can you find out?" answer "I have no idea".
all these may seem like silly little things (and they really are) but this is just a FEW of MANY we have encountered in the past 2 years.
I could go one and on.
many, many little things we have noticed that have gone "downhill" since we fell in love with Disney. and yet, the prices keep going up, up up.
can they keep cutting down on "service" and keep raising the profits? should I keep spending my money there in spite of that? and the merry mayhem that ensues when Nebo and Smidgy stop going to Disney, and their grown children have them committed because they must have "gone off their rocker" and went to Vegas instead!!