I have to butter (margarine) the toast while it's still hot so that the margarine melts all the way into the bread. I love toast and hot cocoa on a really cold day!
Hot. Haven't had toast in ages though. When I was a kid I would put butter on it, then place it on top of the toaster so the hot air coming up would melt it faster.
Have you tried peanut butter AND butter? Right out of the toaster, you butter it as quick as possible then the peanut butter. You have to do it quickly or the butter makes it hard to spead the peanut butter.
Fold in half and Mmmmmmm you have a peanut butter and butter sandwich. mmmmmmm