We get about 400 trick-or-treaters on Halloween. I used to give out little swag items like pencils and necklaces and bendy figures and rubber duckies, because I thought the parents would appreciate not having more candy.
But it got to be too expensive, and also
I realized that with all the goody bag items the kids got for birthday and school parties, they have bins and bins of junky little toys like that, taking up space. I swear, they have a drawer FULL of pencils. At least candy has a shelf life and you can just throw it away!
So I am back to just candy. I picked what I like. I saved money and I can eat whatever is left over.