I think part of the confusion in this thread is the question of does $100k make you wealthy. People are saying no, it does not make you wealthy as many people agree wealth really depends on assets and more "free spending" than $100k for a family of 4 allows for. By government definitions, I would think $100k is above middle class.
Over time, our definition of middle class has expanded into what I would expect more upper class people to be able to do. For example, when I was a child (born 1970) my parents shared a single vehicle. We had one black and white television in the house (for years) that we shared. We lived in a three bedroom house with 1.5 baths. We took modest vacations to Michigan and stayed in a true "cabin". We did not shop for name brand clothes or $350 purses (or the equivalent back then). But we had food and heat and were fine from a day to day perspective.
Now middle class, at least in my observation, is thought to mean cars for each adult and teenager driver, smart phone plans for the family, cable television for four televisions, vacations to resorts, etc. Kids need to be enrolled in sports, dance, other activities that all cost $$$. If that is the definition of middle class, then $100k may not buy that. But that is not middle class living...
I was going to write this lengthy response on my thoughts, but you pretty much recapped them, so thank you for saving me the keystrokes. I believe that our concept of wealth has changed a lot over the years, and we do things now that during the 60's only the wealthy did. We are a very wasteful society, and that tends to cost money. And, we don't live in a bubble. There are people in the US as well as the rest of the world who do not have nearly the things and luxuries we do. Our children, for the most part, aren't having to leave school when they are still kids to help the family survive, and the duration of "kid" years are becoming longer and longer, so that they are not expected to fend for themselves when they are 18, like so many used to have to - that didn't have the option to continue their education until their mid-20's/early 30's that I am seeing now.
I remember looking forward to Christmas, beginning of school, my birthday, because that is when I would get new clothes, and some gift that I had been drooling over (well, not literally, please). Now, we get things when we want to, and young people that have jobs buy whatever latest gaming system, or buy new cars instead of dealing with a used car because they aren't balancing family responsibilities, or even their own home. I see it time and again.
In the "olden" days, people saved and bought frugally. When my parents got our house back in '65, we had hand-me-down furniture for years. They added a dining room a few years after moving in, and I remember my mom painting the cement floor green, and using crepe paper in twists for "curtains" until they saved enough for furniture and drapes. They didn't open a credit card account and start buying things like people do today. Our vacations consisted of visiting family or tent camping. And we also had one television for years. Dad got precedence, and mom, then us kids if our parents weren't watching something. Today, everyone has their own device. I've seen 5 year olds playing on their smart phones, or ipads, etc.
Okay, I'm getting way off track ... sorry about that.