Do you agree with this?

JVelasquez

Loving Disney
Joined
Sep 12, 2010
Messages
367
My DS came home from school the other day with some paperwork from his teacher. One of them was a copy of a news article titled '10 steps to raising happy children'.

Step 1- If you are married have a more active relationship with your spouse than you have with your children. Spend more time in the roles of husband and wife than you spend in the roles of mother and father. The reason is bc a child can feel insecure if his/her parents marriage doesn't feel solid.

Step 2- If you are single do not be married to your children. Have an active life outside of your role as mother and father. Be an interesting person to your kids.

Step 3- Expect your child to obey. Expect this calmly, as if you take their obedience for granted. Disobedient children are not happy, obedient children are.

Step 4- Expect your children to be responsible citizens of your family. From the time they are 3yrs old, assign them chores around the home, chores that mean something. Teach your 3yr old to WASH FLOORS. Teach your 4yr old to vacuum. Teach your 5yr old to CLEAN THE BATHROOM. Good citizenship is a matter of making contributions. Too many of today's kids have no meaningful roles in their families. They're just there consuming and the more they consume, the more they demand. Demanding people are not happy people.

Step 5- Teach your child that happiness is not a matter of how much you have.

Step 6- Teach your child that 2 of the most fun things to do are reading and travel, both of which involve the accumulation of memories as opposed to things.

Step 7- Let tv and video games into your children's lives very little, if at all.

Step 8- Help your children develop hobbies. Btw a hobby is not an after school sport. A hobby is something a child can do by himself, eventually without adult supervision.

Step 9- Teach your child good manners.

Step 10- Hold your children to high standards. You show respect for a child by expecting of the child.

I do agree with most of these steps but....

Step 1- I don't think you should spend more time in roles as husband and wife than you do as mother and father. I think it should be equal time.

Step 4- I can see children having some chores... My DS6 helps me fold towels, bring up groceries and clean up his toys but washing floors and cleaning the bathroom??? I don't think so!!! My DS has asked to vacuum when he's watching me and I've let him but I wouldnt make that his job!

So what do you all think? Do you agree/disagree with any of these 'steps'?
 
I agree with all of them except the chores one. Who teaches a 3 year old to wash the floor or trusts a 5 year old with all the chemicals used to clean a bathroom? That's way beyond my comfort level. I'm all for age appropriate chores which, IMO, are more like taking care of one's own toys for a 3 year old and setting and clearing the table for a 5 year old.
 
Agree with all but #7, which I think is completely wrong, and # 8 in that I think that sports can be great hobies. I have been a runner my entire life. It is amazing and helps foster a healthy lifestyle.
 

I think that's overstepping bounds by the teacher. Is this a public school?
and by the way on number 3
I was an Obedient child and I was unhappy. I was afraid of my parents.
 
The travel part of Step 6 requires money and a profession that allows time off for it. I am all for the reading part, though. Reading early and often is always a good plan.

I get the point of Step 1, and how a shaky marriage effects kids. I also think it is important for parents to not "live for their children" because eventually, the kids will leave the nest, and then you are left with your spouse/partner/SO, and if you've neglected that role for the past 18 + years to be Mommy or Daddy, that relationship could be in serious jeopardy.

And the chores suggested in Step 3 are too advanced for the ages given. But I do think kids need chores or responsibilities.
 
I actually think the "steps" are fine---but for some reason it would bother me that my child was bringing home things to me from school about parenting... :confused3
 
I think that sheet would go right into the recycle pile at my house.
 
I agree with all of them except the chores one. Who teaches a 3 year old to wash the floor or trusts a 5 year old with all the chemicals used to clean a bathroom? That's way beyond my comfort level. I'm all for age appropriate chores which, IMO, are more like taking care of one's own toys for a 3 year old and setting and clearing the table for a 5 year

I am glad I'm not the only one who sees those as unreasonable!
 
Overall I agree with them.

The "more" time as a spouse thing is probably mostly a matter of perception. Sometimes kids do need a lot of attention, spouses or our selves lose out. But, overall, I do think many in our current society have an unhealthy focus on being parents which is not good for the kids or the grown ups.

Cleaning? Well, I doubt the article meant that you have to sue those EXACT chores:rotfl2: It was more along the lines of expect that they can do something real, teach them how and let them contribute--and I like that.
 
I think that's overstepping bounds by the teacher. Is this a public school?
and by the way on number 3
I was an Obedient child and I was unhappy. I was afraid of my parents.

It is a public school. She had sent home other articles as well but this one really caught my attention.
 
Step 2- If you are single do not be married to your children. Have an active life outside of your role as mother and father. Be an interesting person to your kids.

I have troube with this one. I spend all day working and having someone else (my mother) raise my kid. When I get home from work, all I want to do is be with my kid, especially on weekends. :confused3 I guess I'll never be interesting to my daughter.
 
I Would be uncomfortable with a teacher sending home parenting information. I know how to parent my child, thank you very much.
As far as the steps themselves - I have serious problems with step 3. I'm not raising my child to blindly do what he's told. I'm teaching him to think for himself and make sound decisions accordingly.
 
Actually, I agree with most of them, although I am sometimes a slacker. I should focus more on my marriage, but the kids' activities overwhelm us (5 soccer teams, dance class 7 days a week, etc.). My kids do watch too much TV and play video games (but probably less than a lot of kids, thanks to their many activites ;)). My kids really do need more chores (they do put their clothes away and clean their rooms, walk the dog...), but again, those pesky activities. I'm always telling them to read, and I am a big reader.

My kids know that they are expected to obey, not out of fear, but out of respect. Honestly, I can't imagine asking my child to do something, and being told no. It just wouldn't happen.
 
My DS came home from school the other day with some paperwork from his teacher. One of them was a copy of a news article titled '10 steps to raising happy children'.
Step 1- If you are married have a more active relationship with your spouse than you have with your children. Spend more time in the roles of husband and wife than you spend in the roles of mother and father. The reason is bc a child can feel insecure if his/her parents marriage doesn't feel solid.

Step 2- If you are single do not be married to your children. Have an active life outside of your role as mother and father. Be an interesting person to your kids.

Step 3- Expect your child to obey. Expect this calmly, as if you take their obedience for granted. Disobedient children are not happy, obedient children are.

Step 4- Expect your children to be responsible citizens of your family. From the time they are 3yrs old, assign them chores around the home, chores that mean something. Teach your 3yr old to WASH FLOORS. Teach your 4yr old to vacuum. Teach your 5yr old to CLEAN THE BATHROOM. Good citizenship is a matter of making contributions. Too many of today's kids have no meaningful roles in their families. They're just there consuming and the more they consume, the more they demand. Demanding people are not happy people.

Step 5- Teach your child that happiness is not a matter of how much you have.

Step 6- Teach your child that 2 of the most fun things to do are reading and travel, both of which involve the accumulation of memories as opposed to things.

Step 7- Let tv and video games into your children's lives very little, if at all.

Step 8- Help your children develop hobbies. Btw a hobby is not an after school sport. A hobby is something a child can do by himself, eventually without adult supervision.

Step 9- Teach your child good manners.

Step 10- Hold your children to high standards. You show respect for a child by expecting of the child.

I do agree with most of these steps but....

Step 1- I don't think you should spend more time in roles as husband and wife than you do as mother and father. I think it should be equal time.

Step 4- I can see children having some chores... My DS6 helps me fold towels, bring up groceries and clean up his toys but washing floors and cleaning the bathroom??? I don't think so!!! My DS has asked to vacuum when he's watching me and I've let him but I wouldnt make that his job!

So what do you all think? Do you agree/disagree with any of these 'steps'?


Step 0 - Why would a teacher think it is approriate to send this home?
 
I think it's a bunch of crap and the school has no business sending it home. Are they psychologists now too?

To me it's condescending and it would annoy me that because THEY have decided that this article is the "fo'shizzle" that I need to read it. Because my kids need to think I need school articles to know how to parent? No thanks. Add the fact that I disagree with a few of the points and you get garbage.
 
Step 7- Let tv and video games into your children's lives very little, if at all.

To me this is step is like say: "Don't allow your kids to step on concrete, avoid concrete on your feet at all costs." Yeah, good luck with that one.
 
I actually think the "steps" are fine---but for some reason it would bother me that my child was bringing home things to me from school about parenting... :confused3

Me too. I agree with all the steps, but getting them from a teacher is a little weird. My 3 year old has chores - she picks up all the toys in the living room every night.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer

New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom