Before you guys realized it was FL vs CA, I was going to say it sounded like sorority rush! They never seemed to have a clue who we were, but oh boy did they ever. And I never got to find out what it was like on the inside, since I didn't make anyone's cut.
But about the face thing... It reminded me of a friend of a friend. I met her at the mutual friend's bridal shower and bachelorette party (drove to Reno after her shower), and shared a room with the mutual friend's friend. This woman is or was an anchorperson in the LA area, and was drop dead gorgeous. Wore a lot of makeup, I mean serious makeup. I barely wear even mascara anymore, and never got into foundation, b/c it all looks so fake on me and you can still see my skin flaws, so it doesn't seem to make much difference in me. She also used to do pageants, so she's got the poise and grace thing down, too.
Then when we were getting ready to sleep, she took off her makeup, and it was like a different person came out of the bathroom! She looked NOTHING like what she did with the Makeup on. And I wanted to ask her "since you look pretty average like that, how did you know that if you put on that makeup, you could be successful in pageants?????" but figured that was rude, LOL.
So anyway, I figure the face characters are wearing such heavy makeup anyway, and some of the princess makeup really changes the normal lines of the face, that I bet the judges are seeing something deeper than just what the person's face looks like, and that they know that some of the people there are wearing different makeup than they would as a princess, and therefore they might look entirely different than they do at the audition.
I don't know if that makes sense.
I'm probably too old to be any character (other than perhaps Mrs Claus, LOL, of course with aging makeup), but if I were of an age, brave, and in the Anaheim area...I think think of what a nightmare it would be to "go" for Cinderella, but end up as Drusilla or something....talk about a blow to the ego!!!!! (though I also know that the stepsister makeup is also very heavy and different from what the woman looks like)