I think I've waited long enough to add my opinion of the Food Network special. As one of the couples that were featured on the show, I think I can offer the most informed perspective.
I first want to thank my fellow Disney brides, especially Kristen, Dossie and Elisabeth - for offering more educated input from other Brides who have planned beautiful Fairy Tale Weddings that did not cost $70K. And even if the other couple did spend an enormous amount (considering the amount of people she had) that was their perogative and her parents, if they indeed paid for it.
My husband and I are from NYC, the capital of big weddings. My cousin got married a few months before me - a big blown out wedding for 280 - beautiful but not magical - and actually said to me (who makes a lot less money) "I can't imagine how someone can plan a wedding for less than $80K." I wanted to slap her - as there was no way we could afford that. But she loved her wedding - and it was beautiful - so who am I to judge.
To have a wedding in a normal nice place in NYC (mainly the outer boroughs or NJ) is around $150 per person and better. I am not even speaking of places in Manhattan. Had we gotten married at home - we'd have had around 200 people. We knew we could never afford to have the level of wedding we wanted at home - since we'd spend around $30K on food alone.
When Michael proposed to me over dinner in Cinderella's castle, and later in the week when we saw the Wedding Pavilion, our dreams were answered. We decided we would much rather have a magical wedding for half the amount of people, the closest people to us - then a big NYC wedding - most of the people being friends of our parents. And since we were paying for the wedding entirely by ourselves, it was our decision.
So we went ahead with the Disney Wedding, and it was truly the best decision we ever made. I plan events as part of my job, and I knew exactly what I wanted. And Disney helped me stretch my $$$ as best as I could. For what we had, Disney was more expensive than home - but we had 85 people versus 200 - so we could better afford the wedding of our dreams.
We chose to have a lavish themed cocktail hour (for Disney) since at home the huge cocktail hours are the highlight of the event. Carving stations, raw fish bars, martini bars and more are found at many weddings. It's expected - and I admit I like it. I knew we couldn't afford all that at Disney - so I came up with a solution. I wanted Disney to theme it - since I love Asian food - and I figured by sticking to one theme, less would look like more. And it worked.
And we chose less expensive menu options - like soup for the appetizer - but I had them make Canadian Cheddar Cheese soup since it is my husband's absolute favorite thing in Disney World.
In the other couples defense, every single wedding I've ever been to (and I've been to about 50) - other than my own - has given me the choice of entree the day of. It is the norm here. The other couple was not being extravagant - at least not to them. They were doing what they were accustomed to.
We opted for the duo plate to save money.
Only about 6 weeks before the wedding, we were approached to be on the show. They loved our theming (which was Cinderella by the way - with an orange color scheme) and how we'd incorporated it into the menu. The show was devised as a result of the positive feedback the Food Network had received on the Disney Unwrapped special that featured a bit about wedding cakes.
Mike and I considered it - and accepted for the following reasons. We figured it would be an insurance policy that everything would be perfect. (We'd had a less than ideal menu tasting - and figured if it was going to be filmed - they'd take extra care). We also said the cameras could not be present at our ceremony - since we wanted to maintain the sanctity of that. The footage that was shown was taken by our videographer - STVS weddings.
Disney - for the sake of showing more of what they could do in terms of food - surprised us with a few upgrades (Sushi Bar - which we had cut due to budget reasons, Lumiere - again cut due to budget) and asked us if they could do others (Upgraded to Ice Sculpture sorbet server - cut due to budget, Upgraded our cake to the Big Castle cake - which was to large for our group - but we had originally chosen a cake very similar to the other couple. Since Mike loved the huge castle, we agreed - and the mini cakes - which Disney really wanted to show).
So yes there was lots of cake - but we hadn't planned on it. And it was all sent home with our guests in cake boxes provided by us.
All in all, Michael and I were disappointed in the special. From our perspective, the show fell far short of our expectations, not just for how we were portrayed, but how FTW came off in general.
It's not that we think we looked bad per say - or that our wedding didn't come across beautiful on screen. It's just that after speaking with reps at FTW and with the film crew - and knowing how much they shot - we are a bit upset that the boiled us down to the words "Orange you glad you were invited ..."
(Our wedding was Cinderella themed with an orange color scheme. But the other couple was the token Cinderella bride).
We interviewed with the film crew for 1 1/2 hours. We explained why Disney was important to us, how Michael proposed, and how we worked with Disney to create a beautiful and memorable day that had elements of the NYC style wedding we were accustomed to with all the magic and style that only Disney could do.
So when we know what we said, and all the quoted was "Mikey likes chocolate chips" - let's just say it was definately a let down.
I also think that the show was not successful of attracting more couples - or even of showing all of Disney's options - in that I think many couples will be scared away by the prices they quoted.
My entire family was floored that they did not show the Illuminations dessert party which was held the night before our wedding - which was a true highlight of the weekend - something only Disney could do - and much more affordable than the Mad Hatter Tea Party. I admit that the tea party is cool - but way out of the price range of normal people (for the amount of people they had I would say it cost a minimum of $15 - 20K). Though if $ wasn't a concern, I think it's awesome. The hats were a bit much - but whatever.
A dessert party has as much impact and is quite reasonable considering how special it is.
I also agree that they were incredibly remiss in not showing a more traditional intimate wedding - and explaining that that is available for only a few thousand $. And intimate weddings are just as beautiful and meaningful.
Michael and I discussed it and we both said we'd do it again if given the chance. Disney really did a phenomenal job on our wedding - and while most of the upgrades we got due to the show were indeed surprises the day of - they did help push our wedding over the top. The amazement I felt when I saw our cake, the shock and overwhelming surprise and happiness I felt when Lumiere walked into the room, and my guests raves over the Sushi Bar were all wonderful parts of our day. I just wish they had shown more of those meaningful moments.
I will say that I understand why Jerri Manthey stormed off the Survivor set. It's all for entertainment - but editing can make anyone fit a set mold. Michael and I will now forever be the chubby happy orange couple.
But despite that - Michael and I truly had the beautiful wedding we dreamed of. And with out without a TV show - or 15 minutes of fame - the best thing we got on our wedding day - was each other - to have and to hold till death do us part. And there is nothing more magical than that.