Gonna be totally honest when I say that the “optics” of this only matter to ppl who are desperate for Epic to kill Disney aka the folk on certain other message boards. If Disney had instead decided to keep this area open through 2025 like with Dinosaur then I guarantee you the goalposts would have changed to “why are they moving so slow on this, they need to respond to Epic!” Like when exactly do you think they should start lol.
I’m not happy about losing Muppetvision, like at all—I literally cried when the news broke. But i think this type of talk is unfair and unrealistic given the reality of the situation. It’s been been extremely clear since the
D23 announcements that 2025 was largely going to be a transitional year at WDW and the plan was going to be to counterpunch in a couple years time once the new park sheen has worn off. Which is smart of them tbh, because nothing is going to “compete” with a brand new whole park short of another whole new park. Muppetvision and an okayish Italian restaurant closing are not moving the needle for anybody’s trips who didn’t already care about Muppets Courtyard. Better to rip the bandaid off now so they can get started on Monstropolis and have new attractions to showcase sooner rather than later. It’s still not going to be nearly as bad a transition time at HS as when TSL and Galaxy’s Edge were getting built.