Hello there! I am also new to this forum, though it doesn't feel like it after reading through both threads.
DF decided to ask me to marry him after meeting my family and spending a wonderful week together at Animal Kingdom Lodge last fall. We decided to get married on the Disney Dream on the 4/10/15 sailing since we both love all things nautical (we surf and scuba out here in California).
Currently, we have a wedding date reserved for
Castaway Cay, primarily so that our guests could enjoy excursions of their choice in Nassau. We found so many beautiful pictures of weddings on the island (especially Freckledginger's

). Then we found videos posted of weddings both on the island and on board. The videos made me wonder about the setting (loud shrieks from children swimming, etc.). I was wondering what other brides/cruisers thought about the benefit of privacy afforded by the onboard venues versus the itinerary freedom offered through marrying on Castaway Cay.
I look forward to sharing ideas with you all over the next year.
Cheers,
Ashley