FEW Qs:
With or Without Kids? If kids, ages and gender?
Are you looking for Table Service?
Then you are limited to 4 places w/in MK. Oops, forgot the Castle.
If you are limited for time then you have only 5 choices BUT you can take a quick monorail ride to CR, GF or Poly.
That's what I recommend for a better dinner experience. My choices are in order of preference:
1.) OHanna @ Poly (Good Food & Fun)
2.) California @ CR (Expensive - Good Fireworks View)
3.) Narcoossee's @ GF (Expensive - Good Fireworks View)
4.) Citricos @ GF (Expensive - Good for Special Occasion)
5.) Chef Mickey @ CR (for Characters)
6.) 1900 Park Fare @ GF (if I couldn't get the castle)
* Whispering Canyon - if you have more time to spare. It's a monorail and ferry ride. Probably better to try on a non park day.
IF you want to stay in MK to save time. Then, it's broken down to characters or non characters.
Characters: CRT or CP (that depend which characters you prefer).
More food @ CP & CRT much more expensive & hard to get.
Then, Non-Characters: Tony's, LTV, Plaza.
Tony's is Italian food and I'm Italian and very hard to please. No one cooks like mom. So I don't rave about this place. Have eaten there twice and not rushing to go back. However, there are many who like it. Guess you should try it once.
LTV, never been there so no remarks.
Plaza is really sandwiches and burgers. You can get that @ CS. So it doesn't trill me.
MK w/ Character: CP due to cost and amt of food.
MK w/o Characters: Tie for Tony's & LTV: guess gotta try it.
Hope this helps.