Happy Anniversary! What a great way to spend such a special occasion!
We definitely want to go on the Parrot Cay night the second night of the cruise. We thought it would be nice to dine at sunset while we were in Key West. We also don't want to miss Animator's Palate and save Lumiere's for the formal and semi-formal nights. I can't see being all dressed up and sitting in Parrot Cay. Although it is nice, I found it the least desirable of the three on the cruise I was on.
Hope this doesn't sound too obsessive compulsive. I'm an overplanner.