Dining Reviews Part 1

Bayshore Bandit

Mouseketeer
Joined
Feb 13, 2005
Messages
221
We just returned this past Sunday (8-14) from 2 awesome weeks
at the Contemporary and Vistana Resort. I'll break the dining review
into 2 parts. The first week there were 2 families (me, the wife, daughters
7 and 3) and our friends (dad, mom, kids 9,7,2). We are AP holders and
used the DDE card. Which by the way we saved around $178.00 with.
Being a teacher, I'll go by the old A-F grading scale.

Chef Mickey's (Dinner)... First night, good food, decent service, and the
character interaction was very fun. This has become a regular on our
to do list, but we find we like the breakfast better. Grade= B

Liberty Tree Tavern (Dinner)... Great food and fun, the flank steak and
turkey were realllly good this night. The dessert was also fantastic.
Great character interaction as always. Grade= A

Whispering Canyon Cafe (Dinner).... "Candi Cane" our server, truly made
this one of the highlights of the trip. Between the 5 kids, and our friends
who had never eaten here before, ol' Candi pulled out all the stops. BTW,
the food was pretty darn good also. Friends had the barbecue platter, I had
the nachos, and the wife had the broiled chicken. All was liked.
Grade= A+

O'hana (Dinner)..... Another winner on the food front as always. My only
slight complaint was the steak was a little undercooked for our liking, and
when we asked for some a little more medium well, it took forever for
them to return. Grade= B+

Princess Storybook Akershus (Lunch).....Good experience, decent food (wife
and I had the pasta dish), and the princesses were great. A little pricey
for lunch, this one was probably a one time shot for us.
Grade= B

Mama Melrose's (Dinner)......Another winner here. We eat here every trip,
our friends were here for the first time and they loved it. I had the pepperoni
flatbread, the wife had the soup, salad, four cheese flatbread. Everything
was excellent. The service was a bit slow and uninterested, thus lowering
the grade slightly. Grade= B+

Coral Reef (Lunch).....unfortunately, this was the lowlight of the trip. We had
Adr's...P.S....or whatever for noon, were seated around 12:15 right up
by the tank (beautiful by the way) and things went downhill from there.
The service was terribly s...l.....o......w. Painful actually, we didn't leave
until after 2:00!! The kicker, all of us just ordered appetizers (the lobster
bisque was the bomb!!! it saved the entire lunch). Gotta say, this is one
we are taking off the annual rotation. Grade= C- (only because of the bisque).

Rose & Crown (Dinner).....Spectacular way to end our great week. We were
seated on the patio with a perfect view of the lagoon for Illuminations. Gemma was our server, she was flat out awesome! The food was just as
good. Steak & prawns, Guiness stew, Fish and chips, and the Chicken
curry were ordered by the adults, and everyone was very satisfied. Add
a couple of yards of Bass Ale, some wine, and dessert for the kids, and this
was by far the highlight dinner of the week. Grade= A++

I'll posting week 2 shortly, any ??? I'd be happy to help. pirate:
 
Thanks for the great reviews! You hit several of our favorites. Isn't WCC the best? We were there 10 days ago and had the best time!! Hope your return to routine is going well - it ain't easy!! :flower:
 
Great reviews. We are at Disney now with ADRs at the R&C. How did you snare the good view table?
 

We had a 7:30 ADR, and I was trying to be friendly, humorous, and
charming with the hostesses......of course my wife says it's because
we had 5 kids under 10 in our group and we just got lucky. :rotfl2:

Either way, we were quite fortunate.
 
Enjoyed reading your reviews ~ Thanx for posting.
 
Did these restaurants let you split the checks and apply the DDE discount to both parties or did you only use it for your family?
 
Bayshore Bandit said:
We had a 7:30 ADR, and I was trying to be friendly, humorous, and
charming with the hostesses......of course my wife says it's because
we had 5 kids under 10 in our group and we just got lucky. :rotfl2:

Either way, we were quite fortunate.

friendly, humorous, and charming - would that by any chance be another way of saying you flirted with the hostess to get your patio table?
:rolleyes1

btw, thanks for the great reviews!
 
I really enjoyed reading your reviews, especially of Rose & Crown since I hope to dine there for the first time next trip. I'm looking forward to your reviews from the second week. :)
 
Ghost.....Yes, we did split the checks, and yes, the DDE 20% was
applied to both bills. Only exception was at the R&C, we actually had to divvy up the bill ourselves. The 20% discount was taken off of the entire bill for both families, then they just charged both our CC's the amounts we divided up. Not a big deal, except it took us a little longer after a couple
of yards of adult beverages :earboy2:

LiteBrite......Me.....flirt....... :love1: :smooth:
 
Thanks that is great to hear! We are traveling with 3 other families (my inlaws) and it would be difficult for us to divide up ourselves with 12 people plus I don't want to have to trust them to pay me back.
 
So sad to hear about Coral Seas...we'll be there in 5 weeks. Hope things speed up a bit. Otherwise, thanks for the great reviews!
 
Thanks for the great info. We also love the Whispering Canyon and plan it for each trip. I esspecially loved the info about the Rose & Crown. We have never eaten there but your comments will us reconsider making a stop there on our upcoming trip.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom