DD 13 and DH like the fruitier ones- strawberry, lemon. DD6 and I are chocoholics and love the triple chocolate. If you like dark chocolate it's great. It's my favorite thing about BOG. The grey stuff cupcake is okay, but the dinner version is/was different- grey stuff on some kind of cookie shell. That was pretty gross. We've had success with all of the cupcake flavors, but like others have said, the cream puffs tend to be dry.