Desperate Housewives season finale Question (spoiler)

[DisneyFan32WI]

I just remembered that the hopspital director was talking to the attorneys and he said the nurse just quit a few years ago. Now I am thinking it has to be someone who is just "a few years old." Now I will place money on MJ.

 

[Grandmouse]

I think it must be MJ and that is why he was in the final show. If so, that means he was switched with Paige Dash and Susan killed her own daughter! That would be terribly sad.

Also, Mike is the father of the boy that Paul and Mary Alice raised who went to live with his grandfather and inherited all his money when he killed the grandfather by pulling out his tubes!

 

[ICF]

I think it must be MJ and that is why he was in the final show. If so, that means he was switched with Paige Dash and Susan killed her own daughter! That would be terribly sad.

interesting theory, but dont you think that either....

1. Susan would have known the sex of her baby via ultrasound prior to the day of the birth or....
2. The Dr. that delivered the baby, 1st thing would have said...."its a boy"?

Given that, I would think that they would notice that they took home a boy (or girl) by mistake if they had known (or been told) the sex.

 

[TriMom]

My thought was it was Andrew to play into the storyline of Orson leaving Bree. She said she couldn't send Andrew to jail because he was her son. What happens if he is not her son??

 

[Tricia1972]

Bree is already turning Andrew in, regardless if he is her son or not. Doesn't mean that it couldn't be him, but the storyline will have a lot less impact if it's an adult child.

I agree with ICF on the Paige Dash theory as well. First her character looked a lot like her dad, and secondly that they'd have known the gender when the babies were born (if not sooner via ultrasound)

 

[KristiMc]

How about MJ and Roy's deaf grandson.

 

[Tricia1972]

Now that idea has a lot of merit. It could be why we met him in the last episode with the T Rex scene.

 

[AustinTink]

How about MJ and Roy's deaf grandson.

Yes! That could be it. Interesting...

 

[minniecarousel]

ahhh....that was Mary Alices' husband - I kept thinking it was Bree's dead husband, Mr. Van de Kamp (can't remember what his first name was.)

I'm totally confused!

 

[Tricia1972]

Rex Van De Kamp was Bree's first husbands name.

 

[pezheadmeg]

How about MJ and Roy's deaf grandson.

It came to me yesterday that MJ was born on the same day as Karl's son. You could just see them writing that one. It would be even better than him leaving Susan the strip club.

 

[hucifer]

I'm reviving this thread because I didn't see the final episode until two nights ago.

Regarding the nurse's baby switch...remember the flashback of her helping all the new moms? One of them was sleeping while she held one of them. I think it was Lynette. Maybe the switch happened while she was sleeping? Because with all the other scenes it shows the women awake and holding, bathing, or feeding their children.

Just a thought.

 

[Tinkerbell58]

It came to me yesterday that MJ was born on the same day as Karl's son. You could just see them writing that one. It would be even better than him leaving Susan the strip club.

That's a good possibility. Susan and Karl's wife were in the same child birth class.

 

[nicolita3]

Could it be with Bree's daughters baby, I know he was born at home, but I am sure they had to go to the hospital.

 

[gm]

it has to be Susan since she is kinda broke and moving and a lawsuit would be perfect for them $$$$ wise but than again, the new guy that moved in to their house has a storyline for next year so I could be wrong.

It could be Lynette's daughter whose birthday she forgot and finally I think it also could be one of Gabby's daughter and she it would make a great storyline that it may be the chubby daugter and she would no matter whether her daughter or not, she would never give her up and than a fight ensues between her and the parents of her daughter.

Ok I am going on and on and on. I love the storyline of the nurse though.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

I think it's going to be MJ who is not the right kid, and the hospital will have to give Mike and Susan a lot of money, which they'll use to pay the bills, and be able to move back into their house.

I don't think Paul will be there that long, and will probably exit at the mid-season cliff hanger. The neighbors just don't like him, and for good reason.