5:35pm Supper ADR - Narcoossees (2 credits)
Checked In: 5:00pm - We didnt realize that they didnt start seating until 5:30pm We arrived early because we were hungry and it didnt take as long to get there as we planned. Once you get off the monorail, go downstairs and out the door by the Grand Floridian Cafe. Narcoossees is just a short stroll past the pool (a couple minute walk). We even forgot to put DD5 in the stroller when we left the hotel room but it was really no problem since it was such a short walk.
Seated: 5:40pm - We were the first table seated
Left: 7:00pm
We gave Narcoossees the following ratings:
No Characters
5/5 - Service: The service was excellent. The server was an older gentleman named Harvey who was very kind to DD5. I would say he was the best server of our trip though we had great service everywhere we went really. Drink refills were brought without having to ask and Harvey appeared at the perfect times to make sure we were satisfied and to see if we needed anything. I made sure to mention to the manager on the way out what a terrific server he was. The manager actually stopped at each table during the meal to inquire about how we were enjoying our meal. She was very nice and professional.
5/5 - Atmosphere: We were seated by the window with a wonderful view of the castle and the Contemporary. The restaurant including the washroom was spotless. There was also a lovely deck on the waterside of the restaurant. We didnt bother to go out on the deck as we had a terrific view from our table. The inside of the restaurant was lovely with lots of light wood. We were expecting it to be fancier but it was great and very family friendly. It was early so almost every table near us had kids at it. They give kids a menu with activities and crayons. But we did come prepared with our usual distractions for DD5. Near the end of our meal there was a very small child running up and down the aisle screaming till her Dad scooped her up and left the restaurant. It didnt bother us since it was dealt with promptly.
4.75/5 - Food: We forgot to take pictures of the appetizers, we had almost finished them before we remembered.
DD5 was very tired after her first park day and could barely keep her eyes open. DD5 had the fruit cup to start, it was fresh and huge. Lots of berries and melons which she loves but she never had a single piece but DH and I ate most of it. I would give it a 5/5
DH had the crab cakes and gave them 4/5 and said he would order them again. He enjoyed the slaw that came with them as well.
I had the PEI mussels as I love seafood. I gave them a 4/5. They were nicely presented and were fresh. But I didnt really enjoy the sauce so I will try something else next time. It came with a piece of garlic toast. There was enough for at least two people. I had to get DH to help me eat them . I was basically full after eating half of them. I wish I would have remembered to take a picture so you could see how truly huge the dish was.
DD5 had the kids steak meal. It was top notch. DH tried the steak and thought it was great. There were also mashed potatoes and green beans. She never touched her meal and declined dessert so we took a cupcake to go. It was a huge Nemo cupcake with blue frosting. I threw it out after a few days, but forgot to take a picture. Since she loved the cupcake she had at Main St. Bakery I thought she would eat it but she was just never hungry enough to try. But it looked great and was packaged very nicely to go. I would give the kids meal a 5/5.
DH and I both had the lobster and loved it. It was cracked well; but still be prepared to use your hands to get into it.
It was served with scalloped potatoes which were excellent and nice fresh broccoli. The only comment from a couple Maritimers is that we would have preferred the lobster saltier. We think lobster is best boiled outside in fresh sea water. But we gave it a 4.5/5 and wed definitely get it again. DH said he might try the steak next time but I will stick with the lobster.
I dont normally like dessert but for the sake of the review on this trip we always ordered two desserts and DH tried to eat both. He really took one for the team.
So we got the Almond Crusted Cheesecake which DH said was too sweet for him. I tried a bite and agreed that the crust overpowered any cheesecake taste. The plate was ice cold so it had definitely been preplated and kept in the fridge. Next time well try something else. 3/5
We also tried the Key Lime Creme Brulee. We both love Creme Brulee, but this one had a very strong flavour. We decided we dont like Key Lime, who knew
But the consistency was great. We wouldnt get this one again. 3/5
Truthfully if we were paying OOP we would never order dessert. Were not big sweet eaters, were too full from the real food.
Small Mix-up
I had ordered the Cinderella's Royal Chocolate Slipper Dessert as a surprise for my daughter and had to secure it with my credit card. But I totally forgot about it! The restaurant never mentioned it and I didnt think of it until we were on the monorail on our way back to the Contemporary. I felt terrible but my daughter was so exhausted she probably wouldnt have really enjoyed it anyways (thats what Im telling myself anyways). When we got back to the hotel I stopped at the 12th floor club desk. I had hoped that they would help be check if DH should go back and pick it up and bring it to the room (if they were going to charge us anyways). But the Club CM on duty didnt speak English very well (her name tag said she was from Venezuela) and she couldnt seem to understand my problem but ended up leaving a message for the manager at Narcoossees to call me directly. I wasnt upset with the restaurant, just with myself for forgetting.
The Manager (Shirley) was very nice and said she couldnt really understand the club CM she spoke to (at least it wasnt just me). Shirley said the bakery never sent the slipper over to the restaurant, she said she didnt know how the mix up occurred and offered to have it sent for our 1900 Park fare reservation. But since that ADR was for Breakfast I said not to worry about it. I will order it again next year and remember to ask for it. DD5 never knew the difference since it was supposed to be a surprise. I was kicking myself for forgetting. It was written on my daily schedule but my DH put it his pocket after checking in at Narcoossees . We were having such a great time it just slipped our minds. But I will double check next year the morning of the ADR since we would have been very disappointed if we had remembered and they didnt have the slipper ready for us.
Bottom Line:
We will definitely be back. We had a terrific table and the best service of the trip. It was so great that DH wants to eat at more signature restaurants next year. But I will make sure we include Narcoossees, mostly because Ill never miss the chance to eat lobster with a view of the castle.