Caradana said:
She's 16, a good kid, in a committed relationship ... I think you're actually in really great shape as far as she is concerned. I think at this point I'd take her to the gynocologist and make sure she's got a birth control method that she understands.
A great big yes to this advice!!!
Honestly, I don't understand why you wouldn't say, "Look, I'm sorry I did it, but I snooped through your text messages and I really regret it. But, I read some things that make me think you're sexually active or soon will be, and I need to have a conversation about that with you." Then I'd really talk to her, in a non-threatening tone, about your values, the choices you hope she'll make, the consequences of STDs and early pregnancy, etc. BUT, I'd also make sure she got on birth control ASAP.
Let's face it, whether she's a "good" girl or not, if she has access to her boyfriend and a car, and some free time, she'll have sex if she wants to. And I think your window has closed as far as talking about it in the abstract.
And if she's smart enough to be able to figure out how to use a cell phone, she's smart enough to see through some lame "Honey, I was just thinking..." story. Really, what would you say in real life that would sound convincing??? That's not the way I talked to my teenage daughter, and I don't think any of her friends had that conversation with their moms, either. My daughter would have seen through that a mile away.
And as far as not letting her know you snooped because it would mean she wouldn't trust you in the future, well, she shouldn't, should she? If you're going to provide or allow her to have a cell phone with text messaging, you're either going to have to let it be private or you're going to have to tell her that those messages will be read by you, too. What you're really saying is "I did something I shouldnt have done, but I don't want to get caught or fess up that I did it, but I really need to act on it." Really, wouldn't just coming clean and letting her be angry be the best course of action??