Daughters Birthday Ruined Vent LONG

MoniqueU

<font color=peach>Anything with Malibu in it is gr
Joined
Aug 12, 2005
Messages
5,977
Well I have just had my daughters birthday ruined. A
A liitle background. She is 9 her friend is 8, 9 in April.. They have been friends since they were 2. I wAtch this little girl and her brother at my house after school FOR FREE. They have been in the same class 3 out of the last 4 years. She has often spent the night with no problems except once when she was young.
This past Halloween she said she would go trick or treating with my daughter and then backed out giving some lame excuse that she would not be home from her other daycare in time etc etc. So luckily my daughter was invited out that night by another girl so the night was saved.
My daughter can be bruttally honest to some other friends but this one really really adores. She tries so hard to please this one and make her want to do things with her etc. This girl will often not always return phone calls or just say she doesnt feel like playing. My daughter on the other hand would never dream of turning down an invite from her. They are like gold to my daughter.
So my daughters birthday is planned and I tell her she can invite 3 friends. My daughter says no I want to make it special lets just invite this one girl. So we invite her to Goofys Kitchen, then Libby Lu then Disneyland. Oh and btw we took her to Disneyland less then a month ago all went well, they had a good time.
So the girl comes to spend the night tonight stays about an hour and half and then all of sudden out of the blue announces she wants to go home. And is on the phone with her mom to go home. Fully aware that she is the only guest my daughter invited. No offer of I will get up early and go with you in the morning nothing. I just don't feel like going and I want to go home. I asked my daughter if anything had happened between the two and she said no.
Her mother calls me. I told her to put her kids in daycare next week I can't possibly watch them with the feelings I have now. My daughter is just devestated. It's like someone stole her presents back. THe mom told me well she is just 8 and she has seperation anxiety. I told her well I am sick of this. I am tired of your daughter treating mine like crap, used another word there. I told her my daughter is just devestated, I am disgusted and speaking of anxiety my daughter has it now too because she has anxiety no one is going to show up to her party which HELLO they aren't. I was in tears and hung up on her. I honestly do not know if I can watch her kids on a daily basis again. This was so cold blooded to me.
The daughter has spent the night here before with no problem. Gone to theme parks with us no problem. Known us for years. And is with her supposed best friend at Disneyland and she can't cope with all that? Sorry if it were my kid I would of told them to suck it up and live up to your obligations to your friends. I may be alone thinking that but thats what I would of said. It's not like we are casual friends. I exchange gifts with these people. I just don't know how I am going to get over this. To be able to watch their kids again with the same feelings when I know their daughter could turn on mine with any whim, I just don't know.
My daughter at first wanted to call the whole thing off and not go at all. Then she decided she will suck it up and go and we will do a little shopping at downtown disney, still do the libby lu and shop there and she will spend the day with us in California Adventure. I am proud of her for sucking it up and still going and not moping around the house. We tried to give her options of other kids to invite even though it was later at night but she said no to that idea. I am just so in shock
 
I'm sorry this happened to your daughter. I hope the day goes well tomorrow. I know you were upset and I would probably say the same thing but if I were the girl's mom I would feel bad my daughter did that. Maybe she knows her daughter is like that. Unfortunately as parents we can't change our kids' personalities. She sounds like a kid that gets what she wants and is very manipulative. Maybe it is time to try to help your daughter focus on some other friends. I hope it works out. I think it is harder with girls than boys with the friends issues. Good luck and have a great time at Cal. Adventure!!
 
debm said:
I'm sorry this happened to your daughter. I hope the day goes well tomorrow. I know you were upset and I would probably say the same thing but if I were the girl's mom I would feel bad my daughter did that. Maybe she knows her daughter is like that. Unfortunately as parents we can't change our kids' personalities. She sounds like a kid that gets what she wants and is very manipulative. Maybe it is time to try to help your daughter focus on some other friends. I hope it works out. I think it is harder with girls than boys with the friends issues. Good luck and have a great time at Cal. Adventure!!
I think you are a voice of reason and have hit on several good points. I am definetly going to try and stear her more towards people she knows she can count on. And you are right I think it is harder with girls.
 
Just want to say that debm's advice seems excellent to me, as well.
Her "read" on the personality of the fair-weather friend sounds about right.
 

Oh! :grouphug: I don't blame you for reacting the way that you did. I would have reacted in a similar fashion. My best friend was like that when I was a kid. She was a fair weather friend, and if the chance came to "one up", or spoil a special occasion for me, she did it - whether it was making plans and standing me up (she was in my wedding and didn't even show up to my shower), or ignoring me and the friendship when she felt something better came along. Of course, she'd always come crawling back when she needed something (i.e when we were teenagers and I had lots of guys hanging around and interested in me and my other girlfriends and she didn't have any boys that liked her. ) Suddenly she was my best friend again. :rolleyes: I had lots of other nice friends who saw her true colors and told me to "lose her". I should have listened to them. My only regret was not breaking off the friendship sooner. Do you daughter a big favor and let her hang out with her genuine friends and break off the relationship with this particular kid.
 
That is terrible what happened, but you can still make a great day with just your DD.

About wanting to go home, my niece did that once. She has been at my house tons of times, my DD is about a year younger, and once when she was about 9 she was spending the night (her sister was here also) and about 2 am she was waking me up saying her dad (my brother) wanted to talk to me. Seems she got homesick and called him, she ended up staying but I sat up with her for about 2 hours watching TV. The next time she stayed everything was fine.
 
Sure I could of delt with that, she could of gotten up early tomorrow morning and gone with us. Last time she went to Disneyland thats what she did so that would of been an option. She didn't choose that one, she just chose not to go period.
Oh and I do intend to make sure my daughter has a good time tomorrow. I am a mom on a mission. The money I am saving on not taking this girl or the other 2 I had budgeted to take, that is all going to go towards spoiling my daughter and making her day special for her. :cheer2:
 
/
Your right she could have done that. I know I would be angry especially since she was the only one invited. I can't imagine not wanting to go, unless she is jealous? What could be better then DL and Libby Lou :)
 
I am so sorry for your daughter.
I don't think I'd be sitting for her anymore either.
It seems like that girl takes your daughter's friendship for granted...maybe only comes over when it's convenient for her & nothing else to do. I had something similar go on with my DD11 a few years ago. There's this girl down the street that my DD wanted to be friends with. I even set up a special playdate for her to come over & bake cookies with us. I bought everything & had it all ready. The girl never showed up. We waited & waited. I asked the mom "What happened to your DD?". She just shrugged her shoulders saying she didn't want to come.

Well now, years later. This girl calls several times a day to play (even watches for our car to come home)with my DD, & my DD has no time for her - - she's go too many other close friends.
 
I remember my 8th birthday as well... why? Because no one showed up. Everyone was down with the flu. *chuckles* Jaws had just been released, and my dad took my brother to see it, my mom had made me a cake that i had seen in the pages of Woman's Day (an apple tree cake) and I was violently ill. Apparently all my friends were too. I didn't have another party after that till I was 16.

That being said, I'm sorry that your Daughter's friend wussed out. I hope that your littler girl has one heck of a time tomorrow. Be sure to wish her a Happy Birthday from all of her "adoptive aunts" here on the DIS. Enjoy California Adventure... I miss Anahiem. *sigh* I even miss the Santa Ana Winds... Yeah, I'm crazy. :)
 
MoniqueU said:
My daughter can be bruttally honest to some other friends but this one really really adores. She tries so hard to please this one and make her want to do things with her etc. This girl will often not always return phone calls or just say she doesnt feel like playing. My daughter on the other hand would never dream of turning down an invite from her. They are like gold to my daughter.
So my daughters birthday is planned and I tell her she can invite 3 friends. My daughter says no I want to make it special lets just invite this one girl.

I am a little concerned about the first line that I have in quotes. Are you saying that your daughter can be hurtful to some of her friends? Brutally honest can fit that description. While that was tolerable from your daughter, it seems that you are intolerant of this 8 year old friend's behavior on a lot of levels. I can remember when I was young having a "friend" that would almost smother me. She would call constantly, show up at my house uninvited and yes, there were times I didn't feel like playing. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. You allowed your child to put all of her eggs in one basket, not inviting anyone else to her birthday party. When plans changed, feelings changed, an 8 year old decides that she would rather be home with her family, you see it as a deliberate, manipulative attack on your daughter rather than maybe the kid just wanted to go home. The solution here is not to have all of your eggs in one basket. Its nice to have a special friend. Its nice to have a lot of good friends. I would encourage your daughter to expand her circle of friends so that this doesn't happen in such a big way. I think you are very much overreacting. If you don't want to babysit anymore, tell the parent, but to not babysit and take it out on a child because she wanted to go home is petty.
 
daisyduck123 said:
I am so sorry for your daughter.
I don't think I'd be sitting for her anymore either.
It seems like that girl takes your daughter's friendship for granted...maybe only comes over when it's convenient for her & nothing else to do. I had something similar go on with my DD11 a few years ago. There's this girl down the street that my DD wanted to be friends with. I even set up a special playdate for her to come over & bake cookies with us. I bought everything & had it all ready. The girl never showed up. We waited & waited. I asked the mom "What happened to your DD?". She just shrugged her shoulders saying she didn't want to come.

Well now, years later. This girl calls several times a day to play (even watches for our car to come home)with my DD, & my DD has no time for her - - she's go too many other close friends.

I don't know, this must be a "girl" thing because I have had friends of my sons not show up after being invited. You call, you see if there is a problem and then you forget about it. I think when we as parents see it as a rejection it reinforces those feelings in our children. You encourage your own children to keep their obligations but when parents get over enmeshed in their children's relationships, they never learn to work things out for themselves. Spoiling them when their peers have disappointed them only reinforces that "victim" status. I would give her a hug, "say its okay, we will have fun anyway, and oh, btw is there anyone else you want to call to join us. "
 
::yes::
DawnCt1 said:
I am a little concerned about the first line that I have in quotes. Are you saying that your daughter can be hurtful to some of her friends? Brutally honest can fit that description. While that was tolerable from your daughter, it seems that you are intolerant of this 8 year old friend's behavior on a lot of levels. I can remember when I was young having a "friend" that would almost smother me. She would call constantly, show up at my house uninvited and yes, there were times I didn't feel like playing. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. You allowed your child to put all of her eggs in one basket, not inviting anyone else to her birthday party. When plans changed, feelings changed, an 8 year old decides that she would rather be home with her family, you see it as a deliberate, manipulative attack on your daughter rather than maybe the kid just wanted to go home. The solution here is not to have all of your eggs in one basket. Its nice to have a special friend. Its nice to have a lot of good friends. I would encourage your daughter to expand her circle of friends so that this doesn't happen in such a big way. I think you are very much overreacting. If you don't want to babysit anymore, tell the parent, but to not babysit and take it out on a child because she wanted to go home is petty.

::yes:: What she said.
 
awwwww huge :hug: for your DD and please wish her a Happy Birthday from me.. :flower: I wish I could spend the day in Disneyland..
 
I am a bit surprised that the mother of the girl that backed out didn't make her follow through on her commitments - even if it was just showing up the next day to support the party if she had anxiety at being away overnight from her house. One time my DD started to back out on a commitment with a friend's birthday for something better than came along. DH and I found out about it and we made her apologize to the friend and show up to the party. She was in deep trouble with us. Let's just say, it hasn't happened again. I think as parents we need to emphasize the importance of following through on commitments to our children. Otherwise, what keeps it from eventually spiraling into "I don't feel like going to my job today."

And another thing. OP generously watches this lady's kids for free after school. Sounds to me like the mother is good at taking advantage of other people's generousity as well her daughter - without giving a whole lot in return, even if it was just teaching her daughter respect for other people's feelings. I think this is a case where the apple didn't fall too far from the tree. :rolleyes:
 
nwdisgal said:
I think as parents we need to emphasize the importance of following through on commitments to our children. Otherwise, what keeps it from eventually spiraling into "I don't feel like going to my job today."

I agree. But its up to the parent of the guest, not the parent of the birthday girl.
This applies to invitations, music lessons and sports teams.
 
The mother of the girl that bowed out had an opportunity to remedy things and instead she excused her daughter's behavior and said "She has separation anxiety." Period. At least that's how OP reports it. I think at that point the mother of the fair weather friend should have offered to bring her girl to the party the next morning.
 
nwdisgal said:
The mother of the girl that bowed out had an opportunity to remedy things and instead she excused her daughter's behavior and said "She has separation anxiety." Period. At least that's how OP reports it. I think at that point the mother of the fair weather friend should have offered to bring her girl to the party the next morning.

Again, we don't know what went on between them, that child's feelings or what the ongoing relationship is between the two girls. It sounds like they both may need space from each other.
 
DD (12) had a similar "friend". One time she made plans to come over in an hour. The hour went by, dd decides to call, and her father told dd that she went to the movies with so and so. Another time she said she was going to come over, then when dd calls and asks her when she was coming, she told dd that she's going to go to another girl's house instead. It was alright to follow through plans with dd when nothing else better popped up. It's hard to steer your child from that one special friend, but that's what I did because I was tired of seeing dd's feelings hurt. She's since found other dependable friends. I am so sorry that this happened, but I'm glad that she has you as a mom to try to make it up to her. I hope she has lots of fun on her special day.
 
Going by your original post it sounds like the 8 yo has been a good friend to your daughter up until now so I think I would be a little worried about why she didn't want to spend a fun day for your daughter's birthday. Maybe the schedule was a little to long and overwhelmed her, I had problems with that when I was little. I couldn't do an overnight and then all day the next day, just one or the other.

I think the lesson here is to not put all the responsibility for "ruining" your daughter's birthday in the hands of one 8 yo kid. Until your daughter is a little older stick to the several friends kind of party.

Happy birthday to your daughter and :grouphug: for her dissapointment.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top