We were just there a few weeks ago and did the character lunch at CP (with Pooh, Eeyore, Tigger and Piglet) and character breakfast at 1900 Park Faire (with Alice in Wonderland, Mad Hatter, Mary Poppins, Pooh and Tigger). I loved them both!! Both restaurants are beautiful and the food is pretty much the same wherever you go. I actually didn't expect Pooh and Tigger at GF so that was a surprise. The Mad Hatter is a hoot and IMHO not to be missed. He had everybody cracking up!!! and ended up being my kids' favorite! I would actually recommend both! At GF, they saw my ds' bday button and brought him out a crown, cupcake and placemat. I thought that was nice too! However, at CP, the characters do a parade around the restaurant with any kids that want to join in so that's fun too. Sorry if I wasn't much help but they're both good!