I voted for Cape May. 1. I have only been to CP for breakfast so I really can't comment on it for dinner. If you can get an ADR for Cape May on the night with the Clam Bake everyone will get their fill whether they eat seafood or not. The Clam Bake is a buffet with a variety of meats (other than seafood), pastas, salads, and a dessert buffet! YUM! Our kids really enjoyed it and another thing with it being a buffet, if you are on the dining plan the kiddos can eat off the buffet and not have to have the kiddos menu again.