We have a cruise coming up on another carrier in a few weeks, and Fantasy in February and found that both of our large cases had died (wheels fell off or just came apart). I opted for an ebags 29" Mother Load rolling duffelbag, and the wife decided on a trip to the Sampsonite outlet and a 27" spinner (four wheeled case) for her use. They both cost about the same, both have good warranties, and I expect them both to last a long while. It really depends on what style you like. I have ALWAYS used a duffelbag for traveling and have several others, but nothing quite as big as the Mother Load 29", and am looking forward to learning the best way to pack it in these next two cruises.
Tom in Okeechobee, FL