We are debating this one as well, but we have a while to decide (going in July 2010!).
If we end up there for breakfast, we would definitely pay OOP. For lunch or dinner I am still not sure. Dinner is only $5 more per adult than lunch, from the unofficial menu I have seen on All Ears.
There is definite value for a child who is 9 years old or under to use the
DDP credits for the dinner. It costs $26.99 per child, which is like $13.49 per DDP credit used. A child currently costs $11 per day on the basic DDP, making this meal save you money on your child's DDP for that particular day, without even factoring in the one CS meal and the one snack credit that is also included. Between the extra CS meal and snack credit, it would run between $7 and $9 more, depending on the snack price. That would make the child's total for one TS credit, 1 CS credit and 1 snack credit between $20.49 and $22.49 if you do the math. This is a great value. For the adult, the dinner costs $42.99. If you divide that in half since the meal is 2 TS, it costs $21.49 per TS credit for the adult. An adult on the basic DDP costs $40 per day. Add in a CS meal for an adult, let's say a minimum of $10 (but it could be more, depending on the meal, but let's say $10 for talk's sake), then a snack credit which would be between $1 for a piece of fruit and $4 for something more elaborate. So you are talking about a total cost between $32.49 and $35.49 for 1TS, 1CS and 1 snack credit for the adult on the DDP. That means it would be better to pay OOP for an adult for CRT.
Does this make sense or did I just confuse you completely? I don't think I would use the DDP for some of us and not for others for one meal. It would just confuse me (how many child TS credits do we have left vs. how many adult credits?). Although, if it can be done, it may be beneficial to do that and to pay OOP at a different TS restaurant for my sons, maybe a place like Captain's Grille where the child's meal is less than $10 anyway.
Anyone else have any thoughts on this they care to share?