DW and I were at WDW from December 1-9. We stayed at the Boardwalk Villas. It was the first trip to WDW for either of us in at least 5 years. We are in our mid-30s and have no kids. We thought the crowds were very manageable the entire time we were there, and that FP+ worked great. But, I suspect that is because we are only two adults with no children or other people in our party.
As far as FP+ is concerned, we usually arrived at rope drop and got on as many rides as possible before our first FPs started about an hour after park opening. At MK, we were able to get a lot done right after rope drop, especially when there were morning EMH. The most crowded day we experienced was at MK on Dec. 7, when there was evening EMH until 1:00am. We arrived at 3, just in time for the parade. We had not expected to make it in time for the parade, but I was very glad we did, it was much better than I had anticipated. It wasn’t too long, but the floats were all very well done.
We had FP for a meet and greet with Tinkerbell, Buzz Lightyear and Jingle Cruise that evening. We also had a 4:20 ADR at Be Our Guest. As soon as we checked in for our last FP at about 8:30, we were able to stand in line and book another FP using the app. So we did this another 4 or 5 times until FP closed at 10:00pm. Since your FP is considered used as soon as you scan into the line, you don’t have to wait until the hour window is up to book another. On a couple of occasions there would be nothing available, but then something would pop up a few minutes later. Now, these weren’t for the Minetrain or other big rides, but we got on the Tea Cups, It’s a Small World, Buzz Lightyear and some other this way – riding with very little wait.
We would often take breaks in the middle of the day, and I would randomly check FP availability at the parks. It was not unusual to find Soarin’ FP pop up in the middle of the day for 9 or 10 at night, depending on the park hours. But again, that was looking for only 2 people. Even on our EPCOT morning, after using our Soarin’ FP at about 11:00am, there were FP available for most of the non-tier 1 rides.
I was surprised that our wait in any FP line during out trip never really exceeded 10-15 minutes, but was usually much shorter.
The other thing that DW and I both thought is that both MK and EPCOT are a lot darker at night than they used to be. But we could just have faulty memories.