I was so bummed that I couldn't get a PS at the castle for 5/17 (they just added an eride night, so I thought we would have dinner in the MK). I was able to get an 8:00 PS at Tony's - is this any good?
I'd book Tony's and then call the morning of 5/17 at 7-7:30 am. Normally they release more tables the day of. You should get whatever time you want that way!