Cosigner or not?

Update

DD got the car on her own. $0 down and 0% financing! :yay:

It would have been a little cheaper to go with the larger rebates and 1.99% at the credit union but she decided the hassle wasn't worth the extra savings.

We're proud of her. Graduating college in Dec, getting a teaching job in Jan and now buying the car on her own. :)

Congratulations and glad it all worked out!!
 
We had the same situation with our son and opted for him to build his own credit. The difference per month was so slight it was not worth the very slight risk and the plus of him building his own credit.
 
We cosigned for our daughter 1 1/2 ago, she had just finished taking her lpn and needed a more reliable car. I had abosolutely no problems doing this for her (she was 20 at the time). I just told her to look into getting our name off now as she is working full time and would have no problem now. She has never missed a payment or been late, which is why i cosigned. My 19 year old son just bought a house and he wanted us to cosign , and i was VERY leary but we agreed, BUT he was able to purchase without us cosigning! (definately a very proud mom moment). Definately a decision that takes a lot of thought!
 
When I was just finishing college and NEEDED a reliable car for my first job, my grandmother told me she'd co-sign for me to get that first car loan. She made it clear that she'd do this for me ONLY ONCE. She explained that if I made the payments on time, I'd never need anyone to help me with getting a loan again. And if I failed to make the payments on time, she'd take my car and sell it, and she would not help me again financially. It was good advice. I did my part, and it was one of my first steps towards financial stability.

At that point I could have obtained a loan on my own, but it would've been at a higher interest rate, and I made so little money that the difference was significant to me. I very much appreciated her help. It was a vote of confidence in me.

I will do the same thing for each of my daughters. ONCE.

They've been reliable in other ways, and they've done nothing to make me think they wouldn't pay their bills, so I'm willing to help them get a good start.

I would do a couple things to protect both them and myself:

1. If I'm co-signing, I do have some say-so in what they buy -- I'm assuming we're talking about a first car, aren't we? I'd insist they choose something moderately priced, perhaps a Toyota Corolla or a Nisson Sentra. If they are unwilling/unable to make the payments for some reason, I can pay for a car in that price range without any difficulty, and -- like my grandmother -- I'd be perfectly willing to take the car and sell it, if things went badly. I'm not going to find myself in financial distress over a moderately priced car.

2. I would also insist that they not buy a new car until they had a couple months of payments in savings; thus, if they find themselves without a job suddenly, they wouldn't be unable to make their payments. I've always taught them never to live too closely to the financial edge, so this would not be a shock to them.

3. I'd be sure they had comprehensive insurance so that if the car were wrecked, they wouldn't "lose everything" they had in the car.
 

My parents had a policy of never co-signing for anything for anyone for any reason, including stuff for my brothers and me. When I needed my first car loan, they loaned me money for a down payment so I'd qualify for a loan w/out a co-signer. I of course paid them back (I think it was only $1000 or so).

There are ways of helping your kids get established in life without co-signing.
 
DANGER . . . WILL ROBINSON . . . DANGER

1) I would never co-sign.
2) Even if you love and trust your child.
3) Too many bad things can happen
. . . they can turn irresponsible
. . . they can have an argument with you and stop payments
. . . they can lose their job
. . . they could get sick and lose work hours
. . . they could become disabled
4) Loan her cash money if you want, just do not co-sign

NOTE: We have helped out both of our daughters.
But, we steadfastly refused to co-sign loans.

I agree. I will give my son some money to help but not consign.

Sent from my iPhone using DISBoards
 
While I am generally somewhat against co-signing in theory, this post makes a TON of sense in real life:


When I was just finishing college and NEEDED a reliable car for my first job, my grandmother told me she'd co-sign for me to get that first car loan. She made it clear that she'd do this for me ONLY ONCE. She explained that if I made the payments on time, I'd never need anyone to help me with getting a loan again. And if I failed to make the payments on time, she'd take my car and sell it, and she would not help me again financially. It was good advice. I did my part, and it was one of my first steps towards financial stability.

At that point I could have obtained a loan on my own, but it would've been at a higher interest rate, and I made so little money that the difference was significant to me. I very much appreciated her help. It was a vote of confidence in me.

I will do the same thing for each of my daughters. ONCE.

They've been reliable in other ways, and they've done nothing to make me think they wouldn't pay their bills, so I'm willing to help them get a good start.

I would do a couple things to protect both them and myself:

1. If I'm co-signing, I do have some say-so in what they buy -- I'm assuming we're talking about a first car, aren't we? I'd insist they choose something moderately priced, perhaps a Toyota Corolla or a Nisson Sentra. If they are unwilling/unable to make the payments for some reason, I can pay for a car in that price range without any difficulty, and -- like my grandmother -- I'd be perfectly willing to take the car and sell it, if things went badly. I'm not going to find myself in financial distress over a moderately priced car.

2. I would also insist that they not buy a new car until they had a couple months of payments in savings; thus, if they find themselves without a job suddenly, they wouldn't be unable to make their payments. I've always taught them never to live too closely to the financial edge, so this would not be a shock to them.

3. I'd be sure they had comprehensive insurance so that if the car were wrecked, they wouldn't "lose everything" they had in the car.
 
My daughter just qualified for a used car loan. She is 21 and a junior in college, works part time and has had a credit card since she was 18. She already has excellent credit.
 















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top