Coral Reef or Tutto Italia?

[AMonir]

Which restaurant do you think is best for 3 adults traveling to WDW and doing the Candlelight Processional package? I booked CR, but we are big on Italian food and after hearing some great reviews about Tutto, I'm torn!

 

[World Bouncer]

We enjoyed them both.

I think the food is better at Tutto, but....

The special menus, the aquarium, and the diver messages at Coral Reef is a great and fun atmoshphere.

Food & Service- Tutto
Atmosphere and Fun - Coral Reef

 

[jonestavern]

We've only been to Tutto once, will try it agin, but weren't over the moon with it. It's just okay. certainly not bad, though.
Let me say that DH is from Rhode Island so we are used to some terrific Italian food, so I'm admitting, we're spoiled!
The service was excellent however.
We have been to CR twice (once just this past week!) & found it excellent.

Let me say we:
1. travel at 'low' times
2. eat at 'off' hours
3. have solely adults in our party

We have had excellent service at CR, too. The food (salmon sandwich, blackened fish) was decent.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Tutto, the food is just incredible

 

[sss]

Hi,
OK, I have to say that we were just at CR a few weeks a go and I thought it was terrible...very long wait, even with an ADR, slow service and the food was maybe mediocre but especially terrible considering the cost. The fish tank was interesting to my six year olds but it wasn't so awe inspiring that I'd ever go back ever. I have never eaten at Tutto Italia.
HTH
sss