Garden Wing does have a following of fans - those that enjoy it often cite the peace/quiet, easy parking (if you drive), not having to deal with the Tower elevators, and some (although certainly not all) rooms have pretty nice views of the waterway or lake. I don’t love that the second and third floors don’t have balconies - non issue for some of course. You can take the stairs easily but the elevators in the Garden Wing are pretty small and slow if you need them.