We have stayed at The Sagamore several times on points. It is only 3-4 hrs. drive for us.
We have been there at Thanksgiving, after Christmas and during the summer.
All 3 times have been great. We like how quiet it is in the winter-no people-we wnt sledding at the local HS hill.
In the summer definately alot more people, but not overcrowded and annoying. Everything was very easygoing, The Lake is beautiful and you can walk to Bolton's for restaurants, small shops, bakery or ice cream. Also, Ft. Ticonderoga is just north of the Sagamore.
I would love to go to Makinac Island.
My BIL will probably marry his GF who is from Michigan, so I figure that will be my chance to got to Makinac!