Can’t governing with either. We go to both every trip we can. Ate in both last week. Both were great meals, as usual!
Check the menu and see which appeals to you, but Narcoossee’s is our favorite. The seafood/surf and turf options appeal to us, the relaxed atmosphere on the water, the almond crusted cheesecake....just a few of the great things.
Some of the best meals we had at WDW when the kids were little were late-ish at Narcoossee’s, kids asleep in the stroller table side. Get a reservation that will allow you to watch the fireworks from the restaurant, either right from your table or from outside on the deck. That’s some pure Disney Magic!