Dear Colleen and Aisling -
Sorry for the downtime and slow response. I hope I can answer your questions and am happy to PM you the Excel Spreadsheet that I use to track everything (created so my rapidly dwindling memory power is not taxed any further and my family can all access the info). Here goes:
Captain's Gala -
There is no sign-up for the CAPT's Gala required. It is open to all and if you would like a photo with the CAPT (and Mickey / Minnie), you just stand in line as you do for all formal photos. Everyone looks truly lovely when they are all dressed up. This is one onboard activity that others have thoroughly enjoyed that we opt out of attending so I can't be any more specific. You will find that something that you wouldn't miss for the world is just not a high priority for others. I happen to LOVE the Animator's Palate show and Disney Dreams. Those are two things I just won't miss. For others, watching it one time is sufficient.
The Formal Nights may not be on the typical evening due to the holidays but they might. It is a bit too early to tell. When we cruised the Eastern in October, 2001, we requested PLAPLAP for our dining rotation (Parrot Cay, Lumiere's, Animator's Palate, Parrot Cay, etc) Formal night was on Sunday and Semi-Formal was on Thursday. Both Sunday and Monday were days at sea (which I love). They may have changed the rotation in the interim due to a change in itinerary or programming. I don't think there will be anything special scheduled for Saturday evening due to the heavy activity of embarkation, Sail-Away Party (5PM) and DD's "All-Time Favorite" (not): the lifeboat drill (4PM).
Itinerary -
I have also heard that they may be changing the itinerary for the Eastern to include Puerto Rico instead of ST. Maarten, etc, so my past experience may be moot. All of this is completely speculative but that makes planning a bit difficult this early out. I will tell you that we opted for the Golden Eagle Catamaran in ST Maarten and had a blast. But, DD was much younger than when we go this time so this may affect our selection. She was not the snorkler that she is now.
We, also, chose the Atlantis submarine in ST Thomas/ST John. We had a great time BUT another DIS member, MCazer, opted to book the same tour independantly at 12:15PM instead of 09:30AM and saved a great deal of money and had the entire submarine to herself, her family and one other family. So, there are opportunities to book privately IF you shop carefully and use businesses with whom other DIS members have had good experiences.
Colleen, I don't remember swimming with rays in ST Maarten but we did do that on the Western (we did a private charter vice
DCL) and after Erin got over being frightened, she truly loved the experience. I wouldn't have missed it AND it was one one of the best pics of DH and DS.
Aisling, please tell your husband not to worry. Your Disney shopping is perfectly understandable. We have a Mickey bathroom and Winnie the Pooh powder rooms in our basement. And, just like you, we outfitted them from the
Disney Store on Sale. I thought Chuck might balk but they really did turn out cute and we are going to get some of our signed pics from the cruise matted and framed for the walls. As to the rolling cooler...........I think you need to post that one on the main board to get the most recent status. It has changed over time and I have read some folks have had trouble while others did great. I did bring a 24 pack of Diet Pepsi on board in a box and no one troubled me. But, again, rules change so the main DCL board (with the most recent cruisers) would be helpful.
Again, my apologies for the delay. Keep those questions coming!