Depends on who you ask ha...
I love it, and have been going there since before they put it in the Contemporary.
The food is good (nothing too fancy, but I have always liked it, especially the make your own sundae bar!!)
The characters are the best -the classics-Mickey Minnie Pluto Donald Goofy
All in all a win win for us

Plus if you spend the day at Magic Kingdom, you get to ride the monorail to the Contemporary (who doesn't love the monorail lol!!)