First their recipe calls just for cheddar cheese. They use Canadian Black Diamond - White Cheddar. Just regular cheddar is not gonna do it for you. They also use Moosehead Canadian Ale and they use it warm (they just get it to room temperature) both of those things will give you the taste you are looking for. I for one like the taste the ale gives it (and I am not a drinker at all and do not like the taste of ale by it self. If you do not like the taste it gives it you can substitue Apple juice for it instead. I have only had it once like that and it was pretty good.
Here is the recipe I use: It is close to the one from le cellier
Canadian Cheddar Cheese Soup
8 oz. Smoked Bacon, medium dice
2 Tblsp. Butter, unsalted
1 Medium Red Onion, meduim dice
3 ribs Celery, meduim dice
1 cup All purpose Flour
3 cups Chicken Stock, fresh made or low sodium
3 cups Whole milk
12 oz. White Cheddar, Canadian black Diamond
3 dashes Tabasco
3 dashes Worcestershire
4 fl. oz. Canadian Ale, Moosehead, warm
Kosher Salt.
Black Pepper, fresh ground
1 Tbslp. Chives, thinly sliced
2 Tblsp. Smoked Bacon, rendered crisp, fat removed
Method of Preparation:
Heat milk and chicken stock in sauce pan and bring to a simmer. Hold hot for soup.
Put bacon in a large heavy bottom, non-reactive soup pot over a medium heat and cook bacon half way. Add butter, onion and celery and cook until onions are translucent and bacon has crisped. Stir in flour to make a roux and cook 7 minutes stirring often.
Whisk in milk and stock stirring constantly, ensure that there are no lumps. Bring to a gentle simmer stirring often, let simmer 15 minutes, take caution not to scorch liquid.
Remove from heat and quickly whisk in cheese until completely incorporated.
Add Tobasco, Worcestershire and warm ale, season with salt and pepper to taste.
Serve and sprinkle with chives and rendered bacon.
I hope you like the recipe... It always makes me think of Le Cellier. I have been thinking of adding potatoes to make it a little more hardy. What do yall think