I say go for it (although you may regret it when you see how long it takes to print and make it

). I made one for the first time on our recent trip and as we've been so many times thought it would be different to our normal Disney books.
The characters LOVED it, they all signed on the correct page (we put the correct page on top beforehand), and indeed it certainly attracted the attention of the Evil Queen, Gaston (of course

) and Cruella (she loved it very much and kept on coming back to tease us about how much we must love her

). Other characters too especially during the Stars and Cars parade, a lot were walking by other people but as ours stood out they did stop and sign everytime, although Emilie was upset as I'd missed her off

. We even had people asking where they could get a personalised one from! Cinderella told my daughter she had a very clever Mummy and was lucky she had such a special book, and spent ages looking through it and seeing the other characters - so definitely worth it
As I held ours together with book rings they were so easy to undo and take out the ones we had gathered that day and for our next trip all I will have to do is to just add either the new characters or ones I missed and put back the ones we didn't manage this time, so all in all a brilliant idea.
I also printed transfer pictures onto canvas drawstring bags and the children got the characters in Cafe Mickey to sign them with Sharpies, this also attracted lots of attention and is something really special to keep.
Good luck with the making of it
