Any of those were between the turnpike and CP, so still en route from Michigan. We lived in Berkley for 12 years, and used to spend 30+ days a year at CP, so have a lot of experience there. We did mostly camp though at the CP campground. We tend to try to go back each summer to visit family and friends and also hit CP. Drove from Wisconsin out there. Fremont was about 20 miles from CP. The others are basically CP area hotels.
So if you were going down the night before, they'd be on the way, but if you're driving directly to the park, then going somewhere for the night, then going back the next day, it really doesn't matter. Just seems like the main "strip" (where most of the chains I mentioned are) was SO loud (not external, but inside - groups of families/friends/teens who'd have like 5 rooms reserved and spend the time yelling in the hallways and running back and forth). I realize you can get this anywhere. I know the Fairfield was a bit further back and seemed quieter and somewhat "nicer" to us, but again, it could have just been the nights we were there (know we stayed there two different trips - once when our car broke down and we had to have it towed from the turnpike and they couldn't fix it until the following day).
I'd just avoid the Super Value Inn type places - there are a few "no name" places on that strip that have like rooms with 3 or 4 double beds and large groups of people stay there. I really don't think there are any "upscale" hotels (Hilton, Marriott) around there, or if there are, they were always way out of our price range. Always amazed that hotels in general in that area run higher (much higher at times) than at WDW!