CARS Well Kept Dirty Little Secret

[YoHo]

Well, sinc eI just started reading this thread 2 hours ago, your 7 hours are meaningless to me, and since your little quiz has absolutly zero relevence to the claims your making, it really doesn't matter. And, I don't doubt for one minute that you've been in the place. I just don't care. All I want is to have it laid out for me logically, how Lasseter stole this idea. How was he given the opportunity. When? Why?

Again, Thousands of script ideas go through Hollywood's revolving door and are similar to movies that are actually made. what proof do you have that something more sinister then coincidence occured?

 

[Another Voice]

Hum. You want me to provide proof.

Actually, I'd settle for logical conjecture.

But all I'm getting is "I saw Dumbo, you didn't". So you went into the new animation building. No one cares. That doesn't make you any more believable or interesting.

Answering the topics at hand might help your case a little bit more.

 

[YoHo]

And a confirmed dated piece of media does exist. And a link to Lasseter does exist. You want more...try to get it.

Try to get it? Why don't you provide it for me? I'm not the one trying to convince people that Lasseter stole this, you are, so it's up to you to provide the proof. So do so. Or as they say, get off the pot. I'm sure there's a guy on break from Dennys ready to explain how Pirates of the Caribbean was totally his idea.

 

[Sarangel]

Well I gave you almost 7 hours to answer my dumb little quiz and you didn't. Pretty easy to claim you knew those answers after the fact... isn't it.

This is unfair to Tink's Tormenter, who is the only poster to make that claim. You are new to this board, and don't know the histories of various posters. I have been here since 2000, and 'know' most of them.

TT, AV, YH, and others are thoughtful, intelligent individuals who have not asked unreasonable questions. None of them have attacked you for being a new poster, they've just asked if you can provide more than "because" as a reason for them to believe that Pixar pirated a specific storyline or characters.

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

Hum. You want me to provide proof. Well I gave you almost 7 hours to answer my dumb little quiz and you didn't. Pretty easy to claim you knew those answers after the fact... isn't it.

See, this invalidates you right here.. it is called HAVING A JOB AND NOT BEING ABLE TO SIT HERE ALL DAY UNLIKE YOU AND SPEW VENOM AT DISNEY...

I only posed the quiz in the first place to respond to those who doubted I have been in the building...nothing more. I said it wouldn't prove anything. It was just kinda fun. I have a sense of humor too you know.

You didn't use this quiz as a joke.. You used it to try to back up your claim as someone in the know.. and you prove you aren't.. Like I said, I knew those answers too... And I am far from someone in the know..

Ok, what have you proved here so far?? NOTHNG.. You proved you can irritate other members.. You proved people can come on here and spew anti-Disney venom... Until you provide ANY kinf of evidence you will not be taken seriously... So, I am calling you out MUBS.... provide us with a video of this cartoon, pictures, documents, proof it was a copyrighted movie.. and not some dream you had one night...

 

[Mubs33]

A REAL CRITIC, please answer this. Tell them about the Lasseter interview.

It isn't a script...it is a real fleshed out piece.

Thanks much

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

This is unfair to Tink's Tormenter, who is the only poster to make that claim. You are new to this board, and don't know the histories of various posters. I have been here since 2000, and 'know' most of them.

TT, AV, YH, and others are thoughtful, intelligent individuals who have not asked unreasonable questions. None of them have attacked you for being a new poster, they've just asked if you can provide more than "because" as a reason for them to believe that Pixar pirated a specific storyline or characters.

Thank you Sarangel... All I want is some proof.. Until then, I do not believe you MUBS...

 

[ktulu]

One possibility I'd like to throw out, if they are talking to lawyers, they may have been told to keep quiet about it. We know that Disney reads these boards (hey guys!) and mubs may not be at liberty to disclose any more info.

I agree that we need something more, and his quiz might have been just a way to try and show that mubs knows more than just some random guy. Not the best method IMO, but I'm not ready to toss mubs to the lions just yet. I'm in wait and see mode.

As far as things escalating and starting to get ugly, I think mubs might be feeling like an animal backed into a corner, the only way out is to fight

darren

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

A REAL CRITIC, please answer this. Tell them about the Lasseter interview.

It it isn't a script...it is a real fleshed out piece.

Thanks much

Then provide it.... or tell us where we can find it.. You want to be taken seriously, but you aren't doing a blessed thing to back up your claim.. making your claim appear baseless....

OK, example.. I posted here once about the land off the new entrance road to Disney... I told everyone here how Disney has big plans for the area... A friend of mine who IS in the know told me, but wouldnt and couldnt tell me to what extent Disney was planning on using this land.. People here doubted me, rightfully so... i wasn't upset or mad.. but I couldnt give my friends name out for the sake of them losing their job... And if I was able to, then i sure would have provided a picture, drawing, name, plans, or whater else I knew and had my hands on...

Different situation here... You or your friend wouldn't be losing their job... And you obviously know of a place where this video exists... Just provide it and stop hiding behind another memebr of this board, who also, as coincidence, joined today.... if you two know, the provide us with the information we are asking for.... if yu can't, then this will get files away under G.. G for GARBAGE...

 

[Mubs33]

This is in response to KTULU

Exactly! You have taken the words from my mouth.

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

One possibility I'd like to throw out, if they are talking to lawyers, they may have been told to keep quiet about it. We know that Disney reads these boards (hey guys!) and mubs may not be at liberty to disclose any more info.

Too late now to keep quiet.. cat is out of the bag... if they were told to keep quiet, then MUBS shoudl never have come on here saying what he/she said...

I agree that we need something more, and his quiz might have been just a way to try and show that mubs knows more than just some random guy. Not the best method IMO, but I'm not ready to toss mubs to the lions just yet. I'm in wait and see mode.

I am some regular guy and I even knew the answers....

As far as things escalating and starting to get ugly, I think mubs might be feeling like an animal backed into a corner, the only way out is to fight

darren

MUBS only way out now is to provide some sort of proof, some sort of link to his claim.. If he can't for legal reason, then he should never have come on here spewing anti-Disney/Pixar venom...

 

[Mubs33]

It is a rumor board guys...open to opinion. That's all. Up to you to decide.

And it wasn't the original HE that came here. I'm just regular joe like everyone else on here. I just happen to know more about this than you do.

 

[Sarangel]

Too late now to keep quiet.. cat is out of the bag... if they were told to keep quiet, then MUBS shoudl never have come on here saying what he/she said...

Actually, the cat isn't out of the bag, as you (and others) have pointed out Mubs33 hasn't actually told us anything.

Frankly, I think this horse is dead (unless Mubs33 has anything else to bring to the party) and we can all just wait & follow the lawsuit when or if it comes about.

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

It is a rumor board guys...open to opinion. That's all. Up to you to decide.

And it wasn't the original HE that came here. I'm just a person like everyone else on here. I just happen to know more about this that you do.

Then there is no basis for this.. Strictly a person who doesn't care for the movie CARS and is doing what they can to get people not to support it.. Coming on here and spreading vicsous lies and rumors about the integrity of John Lassetter, Pixar, and Disney... You do know, this is grounds for a lawsuit against you right?? You are defaming Lassetter's character by postiing this RUMOR.. After all, it is just a rumor, right??? One that defames a person's name no less... MUBS, seriously, think before you post... You may come across in a better light than you are right now...

 

[Another Voice]

One possibility I'd like to throw out, if they are talking to lawyers, they may have been told to keep quiet about it.

At what point does posting "DISNEY STOLE MY MOVIE" on the Internet count as "keeping quiet"?

Until there's something to go on here, he might as well be claiming that Bigfoot showed him the Holy Grail in Lord Xenu's flying saucer.

Anyway as it stands right now, this is less than a rumor.

 

[YoHo]

At this point, I'd be shocked if there is more. If there are lawyers involved and people were told to keep quiet, then mubs has already messed that up. If as I suspect it's the same kind of stolen ideas that happen all the time, or an out and out lie, then there is of course nothing else to add. There are some people that post here that actually work in the movie business, actually know how movies get made and how ideas are developed. If there were something real here, then it's pretty surprising that we haven't heard of it previously.

 

[Tink's Tormentor]

Actually, the cat isn't out of the bag, as you (and others) have pointed out Mubs33 hasn't actually told us anything.

Frankly, I think this horse is dead (unless Mubs33 has anything else to bring to the party) and we can all just wait & follow the lawsuit when or if it comes about.

I do respectfully disagree... Cat is out of the bag... he informed us that John Lassetter/Disney/Pixar KNOWINGLY stole someone else's movie... but refused to prove it.. By making that statement.. he let it out that someone already has copyrighted material and probably going to sue.. therefore he/she let the cat out of the bag

As fas as this being a dead horse, sure is... MUBS won't bring anything else to the table because there is nothing to bring to the table... if there was, MUBS could have led us in the right direction to find it.. Instead he/she chooses to give us a dumb little quiz... MUBS, you don't need to come out and state here word for word what you know.. Post alink or a site where we can find it ourselves.. That is all we really are asking you.... Better yet, include me in that PM you sent to other people with what you know.. I promise not to share it.. if I find it credible, i will be the first to come on here and apologize for doubting.. Deal or no deal?

 

[tmt martins]

1st What are your friends waiting for .It to gross 150mil like it's going to.

Then it's worth their while to sue.

2nd this may be a Rumor thread but this board is Domain and any and all post can be used in a court of law.( I know someone on another board not related to disney that posted something about a person .Everything had to be released and this person was held liabile for damage to character.

3rd yes you didn't give details but you insinuated and posted that Cars was stolen in soooo many post in so many different ways.

I am not sure if the person that claims to have family involved is just new or you turned them on to this board but it seem strange that all the sudden here is another newbe spouting with no proof.

All I want is to be entertained and you have done a fine job at that THANKS A BUNCH

 

[pedro2112]

A REAL CRITIC, please answer this. Tell them about the Lasseter interview.

It isn't a script...it is a real fleshed out piece.

Thanks much

I thought you were "arealcritic"?

 

[Luv2Roam]

I have not read through all this thread. If nothing else it is entertaining.
Hey! That's a movie idea! Disney -- don't steal it!
I am surprised many have put this much effort into replying to this thread as they have.