CARNIVAL VS DCL: The discussion and comparison thread!

Status
Not open for further replies.
It was our first choice when we began planning but it's also $$$$$$ (although still several thousand less than DCL). So we moved on. But, we just couldn't let it go either as the other itinerary didn't go to Edinburgh or start/end in UK. The whole premise of this trip was that the kids wanted to see London and the other trip would not have got us there. I'm hoping my planning, scrimping and saving will make it work.
Are you comparing it to DCL's British Isle's? I didn't think DCL's was that bad price wise since it's in September.

Check out the Premier Inns in London. We stayed at the Premier Inn at Aldgate. It's near the the Tower of London and they have family rooms. We loved the location and the hotel.

London is not cheap. The tourist sights are ridiculous. They make Disney World look cheap. We did not go in any of the buildings...just looked from the outside. A waitress at the Rose and Crown at WDW told me that a lot of the museums are free. It's something I'm going to research time next we go to London.

If you can take a train to the port do so it's a lot cheaper then a private transfer. It's also pretty easy. We also took the metro from LHR to the hotel and schlepped are bags the last few blocks. Although we've cruised DCL a lot I'm kind of a budget traveler when it comes to hotels, transfers and excursions.
 
Are you comparing it to DCL's British Isle's? I didn't think DCL's was that bad price wise since it's in September.

Check out the Premier Inns in London. We stayed at the Premier Inn at Aldgate. It's near the the Tower of London and they have family rooms. We loved the location and the hotel.

London is not cheap. The tourist sights are ridiculous. They make Disney World look cheap. We did not go in any of the buildings...just looked from the outside. A waitress at the Rose and Crown at WDW told me that a lot of the museums are free. It's something I'm going to research time next we go to London.

If you can take a train to the port do so it's a lot cheaper then a private transfer. It's also pretty easy. We also took the metro from LHR to the hotel and schlepped are bags the last few blocks. Although we've cruised DCL a lot I'm kind of a budget traveler when it comes to hotels, transfers and excursions.

I compared to the 11 day Northern Europe itinerary which is more comparable. We can only travel from Memorial Day weekend until mid July due to marching band camp and school schedules so comparing to a cruise in September is not feasible.

12 night BI OV cabin for 4 on Princess: $8176.00
11 night Northern Eurpoe Inside cabin for 4 on DCL: $12540 CRAZY

Three of us have been to London before but my niece has not and she really wanted to visit. Yes, there are tons of free museums and we will go to a couple of them. The British Museum is free and they have the Elgin Marbles and lots of ancient Greek and Egyptian items which are very cool. We'll probably stay a bit more central in Covent Garden so we can walk to more places.
 
I compared to the 11 day Northern Europe itinerary which is more comparable. We can only travel from Memorial Day weekend until mid July due to marching band camp and school schedules so comparing to a cruise in September is not feasible.

12 night BI OV cabin for 4 on Princess: $8176.00
11 night Northern Eurpoe Inside cabin for 4 on DCL: $12540 CRAZY

Three of us have been to London before but my niece has not and she really wanted to visit. Yes, there are tons of free museums and we will go to a couple of them. The British Museum is free and they have the Elgin Marbles and lots of ancient Greek and Egyptian items which are very cool. We'll probably stay a bit more central in Covent Garden so we can walk to more places.

4000$ less. Wow.
 

We've switched up our 2019 plans (of course as DS would say with an eye roll). We canceled the RCCL cruise and have booked a Princess cruise to British Isles (still in the Carnival family!). It has a much better itinerary. It also costs more but I am crossing fingers for price drops. We have an OV booked but can move down to an inside if we need to save more too. Here's hoping it's our last switch.

Keep an eye out - I have 2 Princess cruises booked for November/December 2018. While I haven't seen price drops, I was able to switch when the "3 for free" sale came out - free upgrade, free gratuities and free OBC (10 night cruise was $100 per person, 14 night cruise was $150 per person). While not a price drop, it means that I anticipate very little on board costs so it makes the cruises more "all inclusive".
 
Oh well... My husband and I fell in love with the plans of the new Coco Cay 2019 & the Mariner of the Seas (which will be refurbished in 2018) and just booked a Bahamas cruise for October 2019 with RCCL!

:rotfl2:

Another day, another cruise booked. LOL

That's right. 4 cruises booked for the next 2 years. :hyper:
 
I'm totally out of subject but have you seen what Royal Caribbean is doing with Coco Cay?

Huh... Castaway who????

It's incredible. It actually makes me wanna go back to the Bahamas.
Wow! That looks like it’s going to be pretty cool.

I do have to say, I really believe that we all have Disney to thank for changing the face of cruising to the family event it now is. Before they entered into the cruising industry it really wasn’t the family thing to do. I can honestly say, we would never had tried cruising for our family if it wasn’t for Disney. We’ve always been a Disney vacation family, then we turned into a Disney Cruise vacation family, and now we’re just a Cruise vacation family. We’re very open to other cruise lines and are happy with any line as long as we’re on a ship.

I guess my point is as much as I hate DCL’s crazy pricing these days, I’m so grateful they weren’t as expensive back in 2011 when we tried the Dream on our first cruise. I’m also equally as grateful for Carnival’s pricing for our first Vista cruise in 2016.

Now the big question is, when am I going to try the new CocoCay????
 
Oh well... My husband and I fell in love with the plans of the new Coco Cay 2019 & the Mariner of the Seas (which will be refurbished in 2018) and just booked a Bahamas cruise for October 2019 with RCCL!

:rotfl2:

Another day, another cruise booked. LOL

That's right. 4 cruises booked for the next 2 years. :hyper:
That’s awesome! So happy for you.
 
Wow! That looks like it’s going to be pretty cool.

I do have to say, I really believe that we all have Disney to thank for changing the face of cruising to the family event it now is. Before they entered into the cruising industry it really wasn’t the family thing to do. I can honestly say, we would never had tried cruising for our family if it wasn’t for Disney. We’ve always been a Disney vacation family, then we turned into a Disney Cruise vacation family, and now we’re just a Cruise vacation family. We’re very open to other cruise lines and are happy with any line as long as we’re on a ship.

I guess my point is as much as I hate DCL’s crazy pricing these days, I’m so grateful they weren’t as expensive back in 2011 when we tried the Dream on our first cruise. I’m also equally as grateful for Carnival’s pricing for our first Vista cruise in 2016.

Now the big question is, when am I going to try the new CocoCay????

Same here. It's Disney who really got us interested in cruising. It will also always be my point of reference when I compare cruise ships and cruise lines as they offer a very good product who brought me a lot of joy (no matter how high the price is).
 
I'm totally out of subject but have you seen what Royal Caribbean is doing with Coco Cay?

Huh... Castaway who????

It's incredible. It actually makes me wanna go back to the Bahamas.

I showed my son (he's 8) pictures and now he wants to go back. We have been to Coco Cay and he wasn't that impressed, he loved Labadee. So now I'm looking to book a 4-nighter in Nov/Dec next year (on the newly refurbed Mariner soon with waterslides and a virtual reality trampoline), and hopefully go down a couple nights early to stay at Disney (and maybe go to a Christmas party? check out Hollywood Studios after it's updates?). Just waiting to get back from our next cruise (29 days!) to make the decision on dates. Even a balcony we were looking at $1200 or so for two! CAD! Crazy...
 
I showed my son (he's 8) pictures and now he wants to go back. We have been to Coco Cay and he wasn't that impressed, he loved Labadee. So now I'm looking to book a 4-nighter in Nov/Dec next year (on the newly refurbed Mariner soon with waterslides and a virtual reality trampoline), and hopefully go down a couple nights early to stay at Disney (and maybe go to a Christmas party? check out Hollywood Studios after it's updates?). Just waiting to get back from our next cruise (29 days!) to make the decision on dates. Even a balcony we were looking at $1200 or so for two! CAD! Crazy...

Are you looking at dates around thanksgiving? It would be cheaper if you avoid those, I think.
 
Are you looking at dates around thanksgiving? It would be cheaper if you avoid those, I think.

My son's birthday is Dec 9 so around then would be ideal. Although the deal is if we cruise on his birthday again we get to go on a cruise for my birthday again too. Mine's in February. Otherwise we can split the difference and go in January but I'd like to do the Christmas party.
 
My son's birthday is Dec 9 so around then would be ideal. Although the deal is if we cruise on his birthday again we get to go on a cruise for my birthday again too. Mine's in February. Otherwise we can split the difference and go in January but I'd like to do the Christmas party.

I hope you'll find what you are looking for. :)
 
Yesterday, I learned that Carnival raised the prices for Faster to the Fun:


Prices for FTTF starting from...

Cruise Durations
$39.95 USD - 3 day cruises on Carnival Inspiration
$49.95 USD - 3 day cruises (excluding Carnival Liberty and Carnival Inspiration)
$59.95 USD - 3 day cruises on Carnival Liberty
$49.95 USD - 4 day cruises on Carnival Imagination, Carnival Inspiration and Carnival Sensation
$59.95 USD - 4 day cruises on Carnival Elation, Carnival Fantasy and Carnival Victory
$69.95 USD - 4 day cruises on Carnival Conquest, Carnival Ecstasy, Carnival Liberty, Carnival Paradise, Carnival Triumph, Carnival Valor and Carnival Vista
$59.95 USD - 5 day cruises on Carnival Sensation
$79.95 USD - 5 day cruises (excluding Carnival Sensation)
$89.95 USD - 6 day and 7 day cruises
$99.95 USD - 8 day and longer cruises (excluding Carnival Journeys departures)


P.s.: Take note that I decided to add a Faster To The Fun section in my first post as it can be an interesting option for some cruisers.
 
Carnival Conquest trip report!

Day 1: Embarkation and sail away
First time at Port Everglades-- excellent and took literally less than ten minutes from luggage drop off to ship. The port parking is steps from the terminal entrance and $15 /day. I have read that there is less expensive parking a shuttle away.
Heavy police presence at the port terminal (not security, but police) and travelling with the ship out of the port area (coast guard boats with machine guns going up and down from front to back of ship until it left port area). Not sure if this is just Port Everglades, or if we have not noticed it before at other ports. Pretty sure we've never seen it before. Also police checked ID and boarding pass before we could even drive into port area.

Ship is more like a DCL classic ship than the Vista. Almost seems like a different line from Vista. Theme is a celebration of Impressionist art (Monet and Renoir are main dining rooms). Lots of details and hidden mickey type messages. Read a quick survey of impressionism before you get on this ship to pick up on details! Some areas of the ship have a disney alice in wonderland feel.
Totally different cruisers on the Conquest than the Vista. Few young children. Plenty kids in 5+ range, but there were definitely more kids on Vista. I was a bit worried about "spring break cruisers," but no issue at all. I suspect that every CCL cruise will be different and random in terms of cruisers.

Food almost identical to Vista, excellent. Air conditioning "walls"/blowers at entrances to buffet area so nice and cool! Second level of seating in buffet area. Lots of space.

Cruise director Chloe nice but not half as good as Matt!! Much less of a presence, toned down.

Steward on Vista was excellent. This time also excellent but poor social skills. Was not very happy that we asked for bed to be made to sofa during the day, but everything was well done.

Ocean view room great, but decor off (pink and tan?!). Drain problem in shower on first day. Maintenance came to fix after quick call. Solved. Air Conditioning in room works great. Bed very comfortable. Free bottles of large water for return guests.

No lines at coffee bar. Small line at pizza. No lines beyond a few people for events or anytime dining. Totally different on Vista. Conquest has much more laid back vibe. Doesn't feel crowded at all but ship is fully booked because we tried to upgrade to balcony a few weeks before sailing.

Amazing violin musicians in atrium. Later band with saxophones in atrium. Steel drum played by one artist on deck 5. Dj on pool deck. Awesome dining staff in mdr. Coconut shrimp entree delicious. Vietnamese shrimp roll app not for me. Effy jewelry push. No gold by the inch push like on Vista. Cherry on top 1/3 of the size of Vista's but still have giant smartees.

Skipped welcome show for daddy's home 2 dive in movie. Lol.
Going home today, will send more later. Have to figure out how to make pictures smaller to upload.
 
Carnival Conquest trip report!

Day 1: Embarkation and sail away
First time at Port Everglades-- excellent and took literally less than ten minutes from luggage drop off to ship. The port parking is steps from the terminal entrance and $15 /day. I have read that there is less expensive parking a shuttle away.
Heavy police presence at the port terminal (not security, but police) and travelling with the ship out of the port area (coast guard boats with machine guns going up and down from front to back of ship until it left port area). Not sure if this is just Port Everglades, or if we have not noticed it before at other ports. Pretty sure we've never seen it before. Also police checked ID and boarding pass before we could even drive into port area.

Ship is more like a DCL classic ship than the Vista. Almost seems like a different line from Vista. Theme is a celebration of Impressionist art (Monet and Renoir are main dining rooms). Lots of details and hidden mickey type messages. Read a quick survey of impressionism before you get on this ship to pick up on details! Some areas of the ship have a disney alice in wonderland feel.
Totally different cruisers on the Conquest than the Vista. Few young children. Plenty kids in 5+ range, but there were definitely more kids on Vista. I was a bit worried about "spring break cruisers," but no issue at all. I suspect that every CCL cruise will be different and random in terms of cruisers.

Food almost identical to Vista, excellent. Air conditioning "walls"/blowers at entrances to buffet area so nice and cool! Second level of seating in buffet area. Lots of space.

Cruise director Chloe nice but not half as good as Matt!! Much less of a presence, toned down.

Steward on Vista was excellent. This time also excellent but poor social skills. Was not very happy that we asked for bed to be made to sofa during the day, but everything was well done.

Ocean view room great, but decor off (pink and tan?!). Drain problem in shower on first day. Maintenance came to fix after quick call. Solved. Air Conditioning in room works great. Bed very comfortable. Free bottles of large water for return guests.

No lines at coffee bar. Small line at pizza. No lines beyond a few people for events or anytime dining. Totally different on Vista. Conquest has much more laid back vibe. Doesn't feel crowded at all but ship is fully booked because we tried to upgrade to balcony a few weeks before sailing.

Amazing violin musicians in atrium. Later band with saxophones in atrium. Steel drum played by one artist on deck 5. Dj on pool deck. Awesome dining staff in mdr. Coconut shrimp entree delicious. Vietnamese shrimp roll app not for me. Effy jewelry push. No gold by the inch push like on Vista. Cherry on top 1/3 of the size of Vista's but still have giant smartees.

Skipped welcome show for daddy's home 2 dive in movie. Lol.
Going home today, will send more later. Have to figure out how to make pictures smaller to upload.

Thanks for your review! Would you say you liked the Conquest more than the Vista?
 
Day 2: Sea day
Went to craft making at 9am. Sea day brunch around 10am. Froot loop french toast. Steak and eggs. Dropped children at kids club for magician show. Went to coffee bar. Checked back on them but they were emersed. Walked around ship. Groove for st. Jude on pool deck. Checked back again, still emersed. Read on loungers on deck 4. Reminds me of DCL. Picked up kids. One made a piggy bank. The other one got into trouble for not sharing. Ugh. Tea time at 3pm. Really empty! Then pizza pirate-- delicious. Never tried any on Vista but kids ate a lot. Mini golf very windy and sunny on top deck. Conquest has amazing pool area in the back. Retractable roof over pool. Always available seating in the area.

One child (the good one) wanted to go to kiddie club while we went to mdr. Learning about Picasso in kid club and drawing Picasso style art. Elegant night. Lobster. Staff danced to justin Timberlake, "dance, dance, dance." Lol. Full band in atrium. Lots of picture taking. Everyone dressed up. They sat us with same wait staff even though we are anytime dining. Waitstaff really, really awesome. Anytime dining just walk up to dining room-- not like Vista where you have to check in at a different location. Much more seemless on Conquest. Live music every where on ship. Love it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!















Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top