The best insurance, Amica. But they are not the cheapest. There are some things that I will not cut back on. Good shoes (my feet are important!) and insurance are two that I can think of.
They do have ratings of insurance on the internet. Amica consistently did the best. Not sure where they are on the list now, but I am sure they are still high on the list.
Another Amica customer here. Every tiem I've looked into it, they've come out the best in the ratings.