not 2008 but 2004 on the Magic and loved it. I found that part of the ship to be extremely quiet. Some white noise from the engine room (I think) but after the first afternoon I didn't even notice it. That room is under Sessions on the Magic so there wasn't even later night club noise as Sessions is the quiet lounge (yeah - like i was the first one to go to sleep at night - I was one of the later ones to retire for the night). Any movement for the seas just helped to lul me to sleep.