I travel for work and rent cars weekly. I can guarantee you I don't treat a rental as nice as I would treat my own car. Renters punch the engine, treat it like a rolling garbage can and basically aren't very nice. They get premium prices because it looks like low mileage, but you have no idea where that car has been.
Also rental agencies seem to have a plethora of poorly equipped American cars. So if an American car, with high mileage (fot its age) and has been treated poorly is your idea of a good car, then go for it.
I think you are very poorly informed and talking out your you know what.
I think the vast majority of rental cars go to business people and they do not abuse their cars. Why would they ? that is pretty juvenile don't you think? My Dh traveled a lot for work and he never mistreated a car and none of the other people he traveled with did either. First of all if you damage a rental car your work is going to hear about it and that is the last thing you want on your record.
who treats a rental like a garbage can? when they charge you for anything damaged or dirty?
What do you mean looks like low mileage? actually you are wrong it is high mileage for the age of the car but since age is a bigger killer than mileage that is good. And how can something "look" like low mileage? It either is or it isn't it doesn't "look" like anything.
then what do you mean don't have any idea where it has been? I know exactly where it has been with a car from a private sale or a dealer I have no idea where it has been. From the rental I definitely know. I also know each and every oil change, tire change and any other repair done to the car since day one. You don't get that anywhere else.
And Rental cars are actually usually very well equipped! Or recent one has everything you could want power everything, plus a ton of extras!
So you are very wrong on many things and yes I do want a car with high mileage low age that has been maintained exactly by the book and I have written records that it has, know where it has been, is clean, very well equipped, and decently priced.
But yeah you are right I guess getting 15 years and over 180,000 miles on one of these terrible cars was a bad thing? and the 11 yr old one that is going strong with 160,000 miles was a bad buy. And the current one that our mechanic said is an excellent car (one of those cheaply built fully loaded Camry's you referred to)
Plus it is pretty hard to do anything to the new engine based on how you drive, it isn't 20 years ago. The computers have taken most of that away.