We did the bouquet toss (not MY bouquet...we had a small one reserved just for this) and we also did a garter toss (chicagodisneyfan, I'm originally from Chicago...got married in Chicago, I've never heard of the garter toss being considered "tacky" up there, unnless individual people think it is...but then, I've been married almost 7 years now, so maybe things have changed since then). But I love the alternative ideas. One idea I heard was the bride presented the bouquet to her grandmother because they had a very special relationship.
I'm Hispanic and I've never been to a Hispanic wedding in which a dollar dance did not take place (people line up to dance with you a few seconds...but they must pin cash on you). We chose not to do the dollar dance, but my family told me that my now late grandfather was so excited about the dollar dance that he purchased a whole box of pins for it. I was extremely close to him so I arranged to have a special dance just with him (no one else on the floor). After the dance, I let him pin whatever he wanted onto my dress. So in the end, I had my own dollar dance with him. And I'm so glad I did...he passed away a few years later and one of the pictures he wanted actually on his bed during his final days were of me and him dancing that "dollar dance." Wow, it's making me cry even thinking about it.
I bring that up because I just want to point out that just because it's tradition, doesn't mean you have to follow it...or that you can't do some sort of spin on it. This is YOUR day, YOUR memories, and you want to look back on it completely happy with what you chose.