We had the most expensive and worst meal with the worst service to date at Narcoosee's. Not sure what it would take to bring us back. The seafood was not fresh, the asparagus was raw (not undercooked, cold and raw when it should have been cooked) the server was so rude and unconcerned we needed to enlist the assistance of the manager to get our food sent back for "repair." Nope. Not a nice place in our experience.
BlueZoo was elegant, wonderful atmosphere, excellent service from an informed server who clearly took pride in his work. The menu was varied, and different enough to be interesting.
For the cost, go with the BlueZoo. The fact that it's not subject to the nonsense of the DDP makes it a much better dining experience as everyone there wants your business and wants you to return!